I don't know that Doreen is either a good recruiter or a bad coach. His recruiting, with a few notable exceptions, seems to be around State's historical average. This is year 4 for him, and State has been to bowls in 2 out of the prior 3 years. He has a chance to go to a bowl this year (they have 4 potential wins left on the schedule- us, ND, BC, and Syracuse) and 6-6 with 2 I-AA wins will get into a bowl somewhere.
Seems like he is right around where you would expect a state coach to be- right in the meaty part of the curve.