I was responding to your post that perhaps I had low expectations of what an ACC coach’s resume looks like.
OK - here's my analysis
Kevin Keatts (UNCW) --> I would be skeptical about this hire, but back-to-back top finishes in the CAA and NCAA Tournament trips gives him the edge over Wes. It's close, though. It's worth noting that Keatts's best season was his first, he's only made the NCAA Tournament once, and hasn't finished top-5 in the conference since his first year. I'm not sure if I would be happy with that situation if I was a state fan.
Josh Pastner (Memphis) --> Awful hire, though I think that was acknowledged at the time. Pastner came with a ton of recruiting baggage and was kind of a desperation hire, iirc. Honestly, Memphis is probably a better job than GT at this point in time. This is a Tommy Amaker and Jeff [Redacted]-caliber hire, imo.
Chris Mack (Xavier and Louisville had a title in the last few years) --> Mack is dope. He was coming off of 5 straight NCAA Tournament appearances, including a final four, elite 8, and sweet 16. We don't have a candidate at this level, imo.
Jeff Capel (Duke associate head coach) --> Capel was definitely viewed by many as one of the top recruiters in NCAA basketball and K's protege, so I think this is also in a different class of coaches than anybody in our pool. It seems like he's a better bag man than head coach, though. We don't have this kind of candidate this year and, to my knowledge, usually don't bring in top assistants as coaching candidates. Somebody please correct me if I'm wrong, though.
Mike Young (Wofford) --> This was also viewed as a bad hire at the time, but it seems like a hire in the Forbes (top)/Kelsey (bottom) range, imo. Older guy, so he doesn't have the same potential as Wes, but proven with a decade of top-5 finishes in a shitty conference. That NCAA upset undoubtedly made him more attractive, though. He's only had a year and VT was a mess, so I'm withholding judgment on how this one will turn out.
Danny Manning (Tulsa) --> Puke. Tulsa was 10-12 (27-28 in two years) before the team won 11 straight including the conference championship before losing in predictable fashion to a pretty mediocre UCLA team in the NCAA Tournament. Lots of lucky bounces that year for Manning and the Golden Eagles and we certainly paid the price for it. Manning actually looks a lot like Ryan Odom in hindsight, though obviously had name recognition and bench experience in Kansas that made him more compelling.
Jim Christian (Ohio) --> I still don't quite understand what Boston College was doing with this hire. Christian was garbage in his last two stops, though he had a nice run at Kent State. Definitely a Manning-caliber hire in terms of his most recent stop at the time and a [Redacted]-caliber hire given his career record.
Our shortlist list reminds me of the following: Odom (Manning), Miller (Keatts), Forbes (Young), Kelsey (Brownell), Matta (somewhere between Larranaga and Mack). Forbes and Matta are my preferred candidates; Kelsey and Miller are next tier; I don't want Odom at all.