• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

Germany to close all nuclear power plants by 2022

RJKarl

Banhammer'd
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
78,116
Reaction score
3,112
Location
HB, CA
This is huge news and may create a boom time for alternative energy investment.

BERLIN (AFP) – Germany on Monday announced plans to become the first major industrialised power to shut down all its nuclear plants in the wake of the disaster in Japan, with a phase-out due to be wrapped up by 2022.

Environment Minister Norbert Roettgen announced the decision by the centre-right coalition, which was prompted by the crisis at Japan's Fukushima plant, in the early hours of Monday morning, describing it as "irreversible".

"After long consultations, there is now an agreement by the coalition to end nuclear energy," he told reporters after seven hours of negotiations into the small hours at Chancellor Angela Merkel's offices.

"This decision is consistent, decisive and clear."

Germany has 17 nuclear reactors on its territory, eight of which are currently off the electricity grid.

Seven of those offline are the country's oldest nuclear reactors, which the federal government shut down for three months pending a safety probe after the Japanese atomic emergency at Fukushima that began in March.

The eighth is the Kruemmel plant, in northern Germany, which has been mothballed for years because of technical problems.

Monday's decision made Germany the first major industrial power to announce plans to give up atomic energy entirely.

But it also means that the country will have to find the 22 percent of its electricity needs currently covered by nuclear reactors from another source.

Roettgen insisted there was no danger of blackouts.

"We assure that the electricity supply will be ensured at all times and for all users," he pledged, but did not provide details.

Already Friday, the environment ministers from all 16 German regional states had called for the temporary order on the seven plants to be made permanent.

Roettgen said Monday that none of the eight reactors offline would be reactivated. Six further reactors would be shut down by the end of 2021 and the three most modern would cease operation by the end of 2022.

Monday's decision is effectively a return to the timetable set by the previous Social Democrat-Green coalition government a decade ago.

And it is a humbling U-turn for Merkel, who at the end of 2010 decided to extend the lifetime of Germany's 17 reactors by an average of 12 years, which would have kept them open until the mid-2030s.

That decision was unpopular in Germany even before the earthquake and tsunami in March that severely damaged the Fukushima nuclear facility in Japan, prompting Merkel's review of nuclear policy.

Her zig-zagging on what has been a highly emotive issue in the country since the 1970s has cost her since at the ballot box.

Merkel herself has blamed the Fukushima nuclear disaster for recent defeats in state elections.

In the latest, on May 23, the anti-nuclear Greens pushed her conservative party into third place in a vote in the northern state of Bremen, the first time they had scored more votes than the conservatives in a regional or federal election.

The late-night wrangling in Merkel's fractious team saw the pro-business Free Democrats (FDP) arguing against a fixed end date for nuclear power, and to maintain two reserve reactors in case of energy shortages.

FDP sources said there would be a contingency plan with one reactor but did not provide details.

Meanwhile the Christian Social Union, the Bavarian sister party of Merkel's Christian Democrats, fought for an exit within 10 years.

Some coalition members had called for a built-in review clause which could have seen the decision revisited, but this was thrown out in the final round of negotiations.

Roettgen said the government had largely followed the recommendations of an "ethics panel" appointed by Merkel after the Fukushima disaster, which called for an end to nuclear power in Germany within a decade
 
Last edited:
Wow that is huge. It strikes me as either incredibly irresponsible to commit to taking 20%+ of your current energy supply out of play or as a moonshot kind of moment. I wonder what types of alternative energy are going to step up and take the lead.

Do you think the Germans have much influence here globally? My impression is that most of the world is going to go on demanding nuclear power and there are many countries with voracious appetites for energy on levels that alternatives just aren't prepared to handle.
 
That's a stupid, knee jerk reaction.
 
I'm confused. I thought nuclear energy was an alternative form of energy, not to mention clean.
 
Green energy. Talk to T Boone Pickens about green energy.
 
It actually may create a BOOM in a energy prices is what I think you meant to say.
 
Amazing that German leaders are concerned about following the advice of an "ethics panel".
 
Germany on Monday announced plans to become the first major industrialised power to shut down all its nuclear plants in the wake of the disaster in Japan,

Stupid Germans ignore the fact that the Japanese nuclear power plants were damaged by a massive earthquake & the chance of Germany experiencing a similar natural disaster is close to nil. :rulz:
 
Maybe their problem was what to do with another thirty years of nuclear waste.
 
Germany gets very little sunlight so they won't be able to make up much, if any, of the difference with solar power. It's also interesting that Germany's neighbor, France, gets the majority of their power from nuclear. So if there is a meltdown in France and the wind is blowing, Germany is effed anyway.
 
Germany gets very little sunlight so they won't be able to make up much, if any, of the difference with solar power. It's also interesting that Germany's neighbor, France, gets the majority of their power from nuclear. So if there is a meltdown in France and the wind is blowing, Germany is effed anyway.

Exactly what I was thinking...plus they don't exactly have huge, vast plains to put windmills. Maybe the next European war will be over how Germany satisfies its energy needs.
 
Last edited:
Exactly what I was thinking...plus they don't exactly have huge, vast plains to put windmills. Maybe the next European war will be over how energy satisfies its energy needs.

Actually the Germans have been fairly successful with wind power, although I am not exactly sure if they majority are offshore coast of Germany or inland somewhere.

That said, I agree that it is perhaps hasty to abandon all nuclear plants.
 
This will only succeed in furthering German dependence on Russian energy resources. The Germans would have to more than quadruple current wind power capacity to make up for the loss from nuclear. I doubt Germany would seek to increase their use of coal, so that makes natural gas the only real option, and Germany already imports 40 percent of their NG supply from Russia.

Wind has been moderately successful on land to date and new offshore farms in the North Sea have some potential, but Russia has to be very happy with this decision.
 
Back
Top