Catawba, and of the CIAA schools
Catawba's Private - but seriously worth looking into.
Catawba is awful. Or was 10 years ago.
Football or academics? Football, except for this season, they have been conference champs for several years. Academics, depending on the department you can actually get a really good education.
I dare you to tell some of the leaders within North Carolina that Catawba is awful. You just might be surprised as to their alumni base. There are also a few Wake professors that are adjuncts with Catawba.
I meant academically. My sister went there for a year and 30% of her class transferred (including her) and 4 students were shot on campus. That school was in a world of hurt then and still was until a couple of years ago (don't know if they improved or not). I know plenty of leaders in NC and there are a few of them that went to Catawba (pat mccrory comes to mind). The school, however, went to hell in a hand basket and unless things have changed my opinion stands.
http://www.forbes.com/lists/2010/94/best-colleges-10_Catawba-College_950115_2.html
Looks to me like their retention rate is still only 70% and their graduation rate is 26%.
NC A&T State University in Greensboro is another HBCU with a football program. Unlike WSSU their program is awful but they have a new coach who seems to have them headed in a better direction (jury very much still out, though).
Also in Greensboro, both Greensboro College and Guilford College are small private schools with D2 or D3 football programs. Guilford College is probably the better school (Quaker affiliated) but Greensboro College (Presbyterian I think?) has some decent programs. Neither one is much of a football powerhouse.
Of course there is Appalachian State which is FCS, not D2, but if he is good enough that's a great football program and some very solid degree programs.
I think Lenoir Rhyne up near Boone also has a football program. That is a very small, relatively inexpensive private school. Don't know much about them.