• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

Mafia vs Werewolves - D8 Ends noon

I should the above was about game set up.

I do agree with Gooner of the timing of jman claim and connection of ryala vote
 
DeacdeTejas said:
D14 is wrong. Gooner is wrong or stupid, maybe both
Click to expand...

D14 is definitely wrong and I may end up being wrong, but I don't know how you can argue that my interpretation of what happened is stupid. It is literally textbook mafia play.
 
DeacdeTejas said:
I should the above was about game set up.

I do agree with Gooner of the timing of jman claim and connection of ryala vote
Click to expand...

Lol the only thing I've said so far about game setup is that the Wolf roll is definitely DDXXXXX which Knight's role makes factually accurate so I literally cannot be wrong about that
 
Am I wrong because of my interpretation of the D roles or because of telling a 1-shot doctor to claim? I tried to clarify that would only be to semi-validate JMan's claim if he was getting run
 
deacon14 said:
Am I wrong because of my interpretation of the D roles or because of telling a 1-shot doctor to claim? I tried to clarify that would only be to semi-validate JMan's claim if he was getting run
Click to expand...

It was just a weird hypothetical - the rolls are separate, so you are theorizing about if the mafia set of rolls had 4 D's in it, which helps us with nothing right now except to maybe know there are 3 mafia instead of 2, which isn't super helpful and will be figured out soon enough.
 
SOmeone explain it to me like I'm dumb (because I am) and please don't use any of that XXXXXDDD shit in doing so but why should we not be killing jman here? Did he not claim a protection role? Wouldn't mafia have killed him? They didn't. I know this is level 1 thinking (maybe level 0) and I know it's not groundbreaking. I'm just asking why it's wrong?
 
deacon14 said:
It's unlikely JMan or mako are on the wolf team. Gouda started the run on manning but switched to JMan later
Click to expand...

I am not ready to eliminate JMan from being on the wolf team just from his killshot of jhawk due to jhawk being just a goon.
 
WhisperingEye said:
SOmeone explain it to me like I'm dumb (because I am) and please don't use any of that XXXXXDDD shit in doing so but why should we not be killing jman here? Did he not claim a protection role? Wouldn't mafia have killed him? They didn't. I know this is level 1 thinking (maybe level 0) and I know it's not groundbreaking. I'm just asking why it's wrong?
Click to expand...

You're not wrong and these idiots are all idiots
 
WhisperingEye said:
SOmeone explain it to me like I'm dumb (because I am) and please don't use any of that XXXXXDDD shit in doing so but why should we not be killing jman here? Did he not claim a protection role? Wouldn't mafia have killed him? They didn't. I know this is level 1 thinking (maybe level 0) and I know it's not groundbreaking. I'm just asking why it's wrong?
Click to expand...

This is a not bad take

We still don't lynch a claimed PR at this point
 
jman do not jail me again my faction needs to hit tonight and I thirst for BLOOD
 
DeacdeTejas said:
I should the above was about game set up.

I do agree with Gooner of the timing of jman claim and connection of ryala vote
Click to expand...

Gooner is wrong about the jman claim timing. He just is. I will explain why this is not the worst thing about the Jman profile, and why he is still not the play in 7 minutes. I want to give the people a chance to work out what goes on in a superior mafia brain
 
DaDeacs said:
It was just a weird hypothetical - the rolls are separate, so you are theorizing about if the mafia set of rolls had 4 D's in it, which helps us with nothing right now except to maybe know there are 3 mafia instead of 2, which isn't super helpful and will be figured out soon enough.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I get that it's unlikely. I posted it just in case more people than Gooner came in hot after JMan as something worth thinking about. I get the perspective that it's so unlikely it's not worth thinking about.
 
Gooner said:
Lol the only thing I've said so far about game setup is that the Wolf roll is definitely DDXXXXX which Knight's role makes factually accurate so I literally cannot be wrong about that
Click to expand...

Oh maybe I misread something or attributed a d14 post to you
 
WhisperingEye said:
SOmeone explain it to me like I'm dumb (because I am) and please don't use any of that XXXXXDDD shit in doing so but why should we not be killing jman here? Did he not claim a protection role? Wouldn't mafia have killed him? They didn't. I know this is level 1 thinking (maybe level 0) and I know it's not groundbreaking. I'm just asking why it's wrong?
Click to expand...

Because his claimed role only blocks one kill, not the other. Its possible he is bad and lying, but its also possible the team he cant block hits had the hit last night and doesnt care about him. I

Regardless, Jman lives today because of XXXXXDDD.
 
ryalaman said:
Gooner is wrong about the jman claim timing. He just is. I will explain why this is not the worst thing about the Jman profile, and why he is still not the play in 7 minutes. I want to give the people a chance to work out what goes on in a superior mafia brain
Click to expand...

A civ special does not wait for 1:30:XX to claim, especially since that tie happened with 5 min to go. If JMan is telling the truth, he claims 10-15 earlier when he's in the sole lead of votes.
 
Gooner said:
A civ special does not wait for 1:30:XX to claim, especially since that tie happened with 5 min to go. If JMan is telling the truth, he claims 10-15 earlier when he's in the sole lead of votes.
Click to expand...

I'll solve this problem in 3 minutes, but this is not actually the worst part of the profile.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top