Old School Nintendo Game Thread - Game Open - Day 123 Ends at 1:30 PM EST

[Eagles_Legendz]

He has a god complex

i love you too

 

[TownieDeac]

would it have made you happier if it was me taking notes on microsoft word and posting in one post instead of giving you actual reads going through the thread as i re-read them?

the bigger annoyance is if you or nonny are civs, being defensive does nothing to help us

 

[tic]

Ph has 2 posts total this game, has been hanging around the boards overall, and also made a claim that runs pretty straight up against another claim that redwing already made. Aside from gooner/eagles/and whatever the fuck rommy is doing, I think he deserves a lot of scrutiny, if not just to sort out the redwing bit.

Nothing says both roles can't co-exist as civ roles. Let it be right now

 

[Eagles_Legendz]

Naw. Wrong. Ph's claim wasn't good. Especially since he's been all over the boards and avoiding this thread.



Eagles, to be fair, this wasn't you shitting the bed. It was Numbers shitting the bed you were sharing with him, and then you walking into a room stinking like his shit.

you're reading that post the complete opposite. zero chance numbers ever posts that @me as his teammate.

 

[AnonymousDeac]

Why is it easier than anything else.

And why did you leave your vote in nowhereville at the end of D1?

Because level 1 says numbers = bad, nonny civ leaned and tried to protect numbers, nonny = numbers teammate.

That's easy and lazy.

And I explained before the lynch why I was leaving my vote where I did. I noted I probably should have voted for doofus earlier when his vanilla response looked bad to me but overall I didn't have strong enough reads on any of them and making a late vote switch would only lead to future confusion.

 

[QT4KU]

Not to derail the current people being discussed but this needs to be clearly laid out so it is not missed and/or misunderstood (now or later).

These words are their own.

Redwing:
I gain information if I break an overtime tie.
(Votes at 9:31. Overtime is officially called. Votes again and breaks tie.)
I learned the character-player matchups for two players, both still alive. I do not have role or alignment information on them. I can still use my power.

Ph:
I have a civ role that gives me a small power-up if I break two ties.

One of these players has to be non-civ aligned. Multiple tie breaks in favor of the town being rewarded? Huge red flags.
If one of them is coming out to clearly buy time to survive to X night to get X power that needs to at minimum be considered.
I'd prefer we resolve it but I've laid it out as best I can which is all I can do at this point.

 

[WhisperingEye]

After reading through, the only solid conclusion I have is that I'm ready to start day drinking.

Numbers wtf post is sketchy but doesn't scream mafia to me. Just super defensive. Dont think him and da are same mafia.

the grabs turds butt stuff is just plain weird but appears to be his persona. Noted that others are saying his sucking up to tic is weird. Probably not mafia together.

Doofus and grabs turds also probably not mafia together. I think we can learn something by puttingdoofus on the block.

This post is poop.

***rocket***

I haven't liked several of townie's posts and could be talked into him as well.

 

[TownieDeac]

***qt***

 

[DeacdeTejas]

As of #1007

Eagles 3 tic manning knight
hoop 1 jman
nonny 1 townie
ph 1 gooner
QT 1 rommy
ryala 1 toogs
rocket 1 parlay

 

[tic]

***qt***

 

[deacon14]

Not to derail the current people being discussed but this needs to be clearly laid out so it is not missed and/or misunderstood (now or later).

These words are their own.

Redwing:
I gain information if I break an overtime tie.
(Votes at 9:31. Overtime is officially called. Votes again and breaks tie.)
I learned the character-player matchups for two players, both still alive. I do not have role or alignment information on them. I can still use my power.

Ph:
I have a civ role that gives me a small power-up if I break two ties.

One of these players has to be non-civ aligned. Multiple tie breaks in favor of the town being rewarded? Huge red flags.
If one of them is coming out to clearly buy time to survive to X night to get X power that needs to at minimum be considered.
I'd prefer we resolve it but I've laid it out as best I can which is all I can do at this point.

Lol Ph actually called it a "civ role"?

 

[TownieDeac]

Naw. Wrong. Ph's claim wasn't good. Especially since he's been all over the boards and avoiding this thread.

Eagles, to be fair, this wasn't you shitting the bed. It was Numbers shitting the bed you were sharing with him, and then you walking into a room stinking like his shit.

you and doofus and others have made this point about Ph, but he does this every game with every role

 

[AnonymousDeac]

This post is poop.

***rocket***

I haven't liked several of townie's posts and could be talked into him as well.

I didn't like this post either but when gouda also called it out, think that clears rocket from being teammtes with gouda.

Not looking to push someone that is highly unlikely to be on one of the teams when many others could be on either.

 

[tic]

you're reading that post the complete opposite. zero chance numbers ever posts that @me as his teammate.

I will say, this is making me giggle. Something is A. Eagles says, not it can't be A, because it's B.

Me:

 

[romanovKU]

This post is poop.

***rocket***

I haven't liked several of townie's posts and could be talked into him as well.

Oh good pull parlay. Need to decide whether an infrequent player soft leans a teammate. Worth pursuing imo

 

[AnonymousDeac]

you and doofus and others have made this point about Ph, but he does this every game with every role

Why does Townie keep trying to protect PH?

The truth about Ph is that he made a post that allows him to cause future chaos, likely with him getting powers for doing so. We're never going to get enough information from his posts and even if he's a civ and survives to end-game, he's likely to add very little value.

 

[Eagles_Legendz]

the bigger annoyance is if you or nonny are civs, being defensive does nothing to help us

that's false - my reads are all legit; i've had about 9 people post at me this round asking the same question. i've addressed it and moved on to other people which then that pivoted into me squirming. not sure what else you want from me day 2.

 

[Deacsfan27]

you and doofus and others have made this point about Ph, but he does this every game with every role

I mean there's a difference in being quiet, but to have two posts in basically 12 hours (I'll cut him a break since yesterday was Mothers Day) is pretty damn low.

I didn't even know some of the other people on the thread were playing until this morning, and Ph is like 4 below the other lowest post total.

 

[tic]

So uh, Rom is Mafia, huh?

How long before both mafs white flag so we can re-roll?

 

[Grabs Turds Bare]

God damn, I don't think I can ever remember Eagles getting sonned this bad in a game before.

I got him a few games ago.

***eagles*** him not being hit means he is mafia right?

lol, flawless logic.

fwiw i also don't disagree with nonny's take d1 about ryala / gouda interaction. i can't read ryala well but he seemed a little off d1 and they both absolutely make that post if they're mafia together re: responding in chatzy.

Yes.

just a horrible stretch for nonny, who left his vote hanging yesterday on tic

You're doing good work. Folks calling you out are bananers.

I learned the character-player matchups for two players, both still alive. I do not have role or alignment information on them. I don't want to release this information now, in case there are negative drawbacks due to mafia powers. I will be glad to confirm if either of those players claim. I can still use my power.

Whew, lad. That is one worthless fucking power.

Are we really gonna iso Gouda from D1 and try to learn from it? Really? This is the guy who posted something along the lines of he thinks he took an extra edible by accident.

Yeah man, Gouda is not a player you can catch with that shit.

word

Mount up. I can be convinced off Eagles if we think he'll provide value for hunting the other mafia team. If I'm Igglez right now, I just straight up say, "I'm mafia X, I will help you find mafia Y - don't kill me today." I listen to that and take it for a few days.