• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

OFFICIAL Pit mafia rankings thread

romanovKU said:
Or you could just say "don't be a dick/angle shoot otherwise the mod can punish at their discretion" and that take care of it
Click to expand...

my ruleset says something like "the punishment will be whatever I deem harsh enough to make you wish you hadn't done it". In practice i would normally RNG a teammate to be modkilled.
 
Official Week 3 Rankings:

RankPlayerTotal Points1st Place Votes2nd Place Votes3rd Place VotesChange vs LW
1Eagles33415010
2Da3050940
3Rommy2661024
4gouda2630231
5ryala253043-2
6TiC2231003
7gooner214001-3
8GAT184010-2
9QT1740028
10GoalieMom14000115
11Nonny126010-1
12toogs121000-4
13Tejas1080000
14D14960001
15Bym89000-3
16redwing8400011
17DeacsFan2783000-6
18parlay/WhisperingEye6800010
19SD3610004
20Knight/GrabTurds61000-6

Others receiving votes: Townie (51), Northern/Chaos (47), Jman (45), Manning/Jhawk (39), Hoop (37), Mako (35), Numbers (26), Tim (24), Damo (21), Juice (7), dv7 (5), WFU03 (1)

Dropped out of T20: Jman (was 16), Numbers (18), Townie (19), and Tim (20)

Big movers of the week: Goaliemom debuts at #10 after being previously outside the T20. Redwing also moves into the T20 this week along with Parlay.
 
Parlay going HAM on Nonny/Toog has me slizzered
 
Would it be "bastard modding" to give out the makeup of the game from the start as in X civs, Y indy, and Z mafia.

Then don't announce what affiliation any players are that died, but instead after every 3 nights on the next day break announce X-A civs, Y-B indy, and Z-C mafia are left?
 
deacvision7 said:
Would it be "bastard modding" to give out the makeup of the game from the start as in X civs, Y indy, and Z mafia.

Then don't announce what affiliation any players are that died, but instead after every 3 nights on the next day break announce X-A civs, Y-B indy, and Z-C mafia are left?
Click to expand...

Yes
 
deacvision7 said:
Would it be "bastard modding" to give out the makeup of the game from the start as in X civs, Y indy, and Z mafia.

Then don't announce what affiliation any players are that died, but instead after every 3 nights on the next day break announce X-A civs, Y-B indy, and Z-C mafia are left?
Click to expand...

you should try modding a regular mafia game before breaking it. kinda like picasso had to learn the rules of painting before flipping them out
 
romanovKU said:
you should try modding a regular mafia game before breaking it. kinda like picasso had to learn the rules of painting before flipping them out
Click to expand...

damn me for giving out so much rep. Why did I waste one on knight?
 
regular mafia games are sooooo borrringggg tho even with great themes/player roles. (see this week's game -- bym's theme and roles were awesome, and the game was still figured out super quick because we are in a rut style wise *imo*)

I believe that we need inventive ideas for game mechanics


so instead of rejecting it out of hand, why would establishing just raw numbers of civs/(any)indies/mafia at the start be a bad idea?

then if thats a good idea, why would not telling the identity of each person killed be a bad idea? when I've played mafia/werewolf in person you don't learn identities until the end of the game...

and added to that, why would giving everyone a general idea of where the game stood be a bad idea every 3rd day; i.e., day 1/4/7/etc.?



I get that it's me and I have crazy out there ideas and will overthink any game I design to death, but tell me WHY the idea is bad please. Thanks in advance.
 
Someone wake up GAT. I need to get this done while the salt is fresh.
 
I'm open to a DV7 game as long as we have a backup game ready to roll at 10:35 on Monday.
 
deacvision7 said:
Would it be "bastard modding" to give out the makeup of the game from the start as in X civs, Y indy, and Z mafia.

Then don't announce what affiliation any players are that died, but instead after every 3 nights on the next day break announce X-A civs, Y-B indy, and Z-C mafia are left?
Click to expand...

I don't think it is bastard modding if you announce how the game will work ahead of time. It is just getting further away from the game we currently play. Not necessarily bad, just different.
 
If there gets to be a hole in the schedule, let me know. I think I could figure out a fun Survivor (TV Series) Mafia.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top