• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

Better Call Saul, The Mafia Game. Indies Win! Gooner, GAT and Duff

for my gripes about balance and gameplay, credit to mods for trying to run an insanely complicated game. don't beat yourself up, mods.
 
Gooner said:
ggwp to all except me who tried to do literally everything to lose this game and somehow luckboxed my way through
Click to expand...

What was it I told Da back in the day?

Oh yes, that’s right...

DistortedPiercingBug-size_restricted.gif


Do thank the Salamanca Mafia for your win.
 
Just read gooner's role, that's very powerful. Should be in this game. So was the Duff and Gooner anger show a show or did you already know each other? I even considered it was a posting restriction.
 
Gaterrapin said:
And yet here i am. Alive at the end. Never once being protected. Never once rb-ing a kill.
Click to expand...

you were my final investigation the night i died; you had me fooled until the numbers ID thing
 
TownieDeac said:
for my gripes about balance and gameplay, credit to mods for trying to run an insanely complicated game. don't beat yourself up, mods.
Click to expand...

Don't even feel a little bad, mods

Games that are different from the norm are great and makes people think differently not only in that game but future games as well. At least that's my opinion.

It won't always go great, but its awesome to try new things.
 
BostonDeac said:
Fine but had literally no effect on the outcome of the game
Click to expand...

Incorrect. One more mislynch gained if you don't, or rommy doesn't do whatever the fuck he did (will we ever see him again)
 
TownieDeac said:
i felt like i played better than gooner but he still won

glad we didn't waste an investigation on him since he was able to turn, but i was so mad nobody was able to bring up his tie to duff i brought up frequently in thread
Click to expand...

i worked continually to steer the conversation away from gooner in our chat. to the point where i was sure gouda and d14 were going to figure it out.

BTW, this may sting more but tim, gouda, and d14 actually deserve a ton of credit for the gooner win. they worked their asses off helping me avoid or correct stupid mistakes. Full credit to all 3 of them.

DV7 just ate Jersey Mikes and bitched about Knight.
 
WhisperingEye said:
I believe the only hidden role I havent reveal is this:

PH = Chuck McGill (Civ) - You are a renowned attorney and you are not shy about letting people know it. Once during each day, you must post a pompous post boasting about your greatness. You win with the town.
Hidden - Once Jimmy leaves the firm and becomes Saul, Chuck will receive the following message. Your brother Jimmy has left the firm. You are concerned about the path he is on. Each night you will search for him. If you find him, you will learn what he is doing (his current alignment).
Click to expand...

I think PH not getting to search until after Gooner found a recruit was too much of a handicap. Gooner was already superpowered to begin with, and this was even more in his favor. I understand that you want roles to really match up in game with the show, but sometimes considerations need to be made for gameplay purposes. Just constructive criticism, as I have made the same mistake in the past.
 
TownieDeac said:
you were my final investigation the night i died; you had me fooled until the numbers ID thing
Click to expand...

Whats crazy about that is i had literally no idea about the IDs. I was legit figuring that out real-time in the thread.
 
Better Call Saul, The Mafia Game. Day 12 ends 1:00pm est

TownieDeac said:
took a civ out of the game that wasn't killed by mafia or indy

how did it feel at endgame all by yourself? vindicated?
Click to expand...

That civ would’ve been killed the next day so again didn’t matter. Having him live one more day would not have won the game for the civs
 
Last edited:
Gaterrapin said:
i worked continually to steer the conversation away from gooner in our chat. to the point where i was sure gouda and d14 were going to figure it out.

BTW, this may sting more but tim, gouda, and d14 actually deserve a ton of credit for the gooner win. they worked their asses off helping me avoid or correct stupid mistakes. Full credit to all 3 of them.

DV7 just ate Jersey Mikes and bitched about Knight.
Click to expand...

lol, a bit unfair.

I wasn't even around Tuesday or Wednesday.


Mostly accurate for today tho.

1) nom nom nom
2) just don't let knight win. ever. his maf ego is already overinflated.
 
Toogs said:
I need help understanding the Mrs Nguyen thing when I shot numbers
Click to expand...

There was no Mrs Nyugen in the game for you to kill. That player was gone. Numbers bought a new identity which basically was a jailer type role removing him from the game and blocking your hit.
 
Gaterrapin said:
i worked continually to steer the conversation away from gooner in our chat. to the point where i was sure gouda and d14 were going to figure it out.

BTW, this may sting more but tim, gouda, and d14 actually deserve a ton of credit for the gooner win. they worked their asses off helping me avoid or correct stupid mistakes. Full credit to all 3 of them.

I legit wondered why you weren’t ever talking about gooner. I was already dead so I didn’t bother with it. But yes, that does sting more. I basically provided the posts to help you lynch numbers. And tim vetted your fake claim. Ouch.
DV7 just ate Jersey Mikes and bitched about Knight.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top