Well, I should be able to do the bulk in the WSM and only have to do 2-3 butts on my grill setup to smoke. The grilled/oven finished butts won't have as good of a bark, but they'll be mixed in with the butts that go the distance on the smoker. I could just smoke them all of the way on the grill, but it takes more work to keep smoking for a long time. I'd rather not be adding fuel all day to the grill while the WSM is mostly set it and forget it.
Everything is going to need to be reheated, so I need to come up with a middle of the road dip I can mix in during the reheating process to keep things moist. Anyone have a suggestion? Something Lexington style?