• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

Avengers Endfinity Wargame Mafia; MAFIA WINS

I'm trying to figure out how I'm goon's lowest rated civ given that I was on half the mafia before the rest. A full letter grade lower than tcc who wasn't on any mafia all game.

I was thinking about pulling out an old Captain America: Civil War game I designed awhile back. Probably wouldn't do it now since so many people chafed at the source material for this one. I knew I had shared it with someone, but I forgot who. I just looked it up. It was goon.
 
PhDeac said:
I'm trying to figure out how I'm goon's lowest rated civ given that I was on half the mafia before the rest. A full letter grade lower than tcc who wasn't on any mafia all game.

I was thinking about pulling out an old Captain America: Civil War game I designed awhile back. Probably wouldn't do it now since so many people chafed at the source material for this one. I knew I had shared it with someone, but I forgot who. I just looked it up. It was goon.
Click to expand...

To be clear - despite my issues which I’ve shared - I thought you played pretty well in the mid rounds.
 
PhDeac said:
I'm trying to figure out how I'm goon's lowest rated civ given that I was on half the mafia before the rest. A full letter grade lower than tcc who wasn't on any mafia all game.

I was thinking about pulling out an old Captain America: Civil War game I designed awhile back. Probably wouldn't do it now since so many people chafed at the source material for this one. I knew I had shared it with someone, but I forgot who. I just looked it up. It was goon.
Click to expand...

Eagles_Legendz said:
To be clear - despite my issues which I’ve shared - I thought you played pretty well in the mid rounds.
Click to expand...

Fixed.
 
Wakeforest22890 said:
I know others disagree (had a brief chat in the dead room) but the tcc and mako votes for the person who just got lynched were absolutely egregious. With that in mind now people can easily replicate as mafia but for two relatively new players and/or outsiders who we haven’t played with there was no way they weren’t civs
Click to expand...

Mafia dumbtelling like that intentionally is, at best, something that we'd probably need to have a real conversation about. Winning is fun and all, but that is not an aboveboard play.
 
PhDeac said:
I'm trying to figure out how I'm goon's lowest rated civ given that I was on half the mafia before the rest. A full letter grade lower than tcc who wasn't on any mafia all game.

I was thinking about pulling out an old Captain America: Civil War game I designed awhile back. Probably wouldn't do it now since so many people chafed at the source material for this one. I knew I had shared it with someone, but I forgot who. I just looked it up. It was goon.
Click to expand...

yL9PPjz.gif
 
ryalaman said:
Mafia dumbtelling like that intentionally is, at best, something that we'd probably need to have a real conversation about. Winning is fun and all, but that is not an aboveboard play.
Click to expand...

Right but if you address it from a mafia dumbtell vantage point you have to just punish/kill the person regardless of affiliation because if someone dumb tells accidentally as a civ and then doesn’t die then it’s even better confirmation they’re not mafia.
 
You can’t kill people for dumbtells. People make mistakes (i.e. me getting swamped and not realizing GAt wasn’t claiming cop). If it’s not intentional (and it’s usually easy to see if it is), it’s just a byproduct of the game.
 
I think that's correct it sucks but u just have to let mafia do it
@numbers
 
Post Count (includes postgame)
rommy: 312
bym: 251
ryala: 197
SD3: 165
shiny: 162
Gooner: 151
Da: 136
Juice: 132
Eagles: 117
WFU03: 110
numbers: 102
Ph: 87
GAT: 83
GoalieMom: 82
tcc: 77
toogs: 57
gouda: 57
Townie: 52
dv7: 49
redwing: 46
mako: 40
damo: 21
JMan: 21
tim: 20
Knight: 18
bern: 15
BBD: 5
Nonny: 1
 
Gooner said:
Post Count (includes postgame)
rommy: 312
bym: 251
ryala: 197
SD3: 165
shiny: 162
Gooner: 151
Da: 136
Juice: 132
Eagles: 117
WFU03: 110
numbers: 102
Ph: 87
GAT: 83
GoalieMom: 82
tcc: 77
toogs: 57
gouda: 57
Townie: 52
dv7: 49
redwing: 46
mako: 40
damo: 21
JMan: 21
tim: 20
Knight: 18
bern: 15
BBD: 5
Nonny: 1
Click to expand...

THE CHAMP IS HERE
 
Gooner said:
Post Count (includes postgame)
rommy: 312
bym: 251
ryala: 197
SD3: 165
shiny: 162
Gooner: 151
Da: 136
Juice: 132
Eagles: 117
WFU03: 110
numbers: 102
Ph: 87
GAT: 83
GoalieMom: 82
tcc: 77
toogs: 57
gouda: 57
Townie: 52
dv7: 49
redwing: 46
mako: 40
damo: 21
JMan: 21
tim: 20
Knight: 18
bern: 15
BBD: 5
Nonny: 1
Click to expand...
Strong
 
Gooner said:
Post Count (includes postgame)
rommy: 312
bym: 251
ryala: 197
SD3: 165
shiny: 162
Gooner: 151
Da: 136
Juice: 132
Eagles: 117
WFU03: 110
numbers: 102
Ph: 87
GAT: 83
GoalieMom: 82
tcc: 77
toogs: 57
gouda: 57
Townie: 52
dv7: 49
redwing: 46
mako: 40
damo: 21
JMan: 21
tim: 20
Knight: 18
bern: 15
BBD: 5
Nonny: 1
Click to expand...
fuck-my-lifefmlgleetvcrying.gif
 
Eagles_Legendz said:
You can’t kill people for dumbtells. People make mistakes (i.e. me getting swamped and not realizing GAt wasn’t claiming cop). If it’s not intentional (and it’s usually easy to see if it is), it’s just a byproduct of the game.
Click to expand...

Yeah agreed overall. The ones in this game were just particularly obvious given when they occurred relative to the previous kill and who the two were who did it.
 
Gooner said:
Post Count (includes postgame)
rommy: 312
bym: 251
ryala: 197
SD3: 165
shiny: 162
Gooner: 151
Da: 136
Juice: 132
Eagles: 117
WFU03: 110
numbers: 102
Ph: 87
GAT: 83
GoalieMom: 82
tcc: 77
toogs: 57
gouda: 57
Townie: 52
dv7: 49
redwing: 46
mako: 40
damo: 21
JMan: 21
tim: 20
Knight: 18
bern: 15
BBD: 5
Nonny: 1
Click to expand...

I was so far ahead when I died. I was just assuming mafia killed me because toogs didnt want to read any more of my posts.
 
damo: 21
JMan: 21
tim: 20
Knight: 18
bern: 15
BBD: 5
Nonny: 1

why knight was the D1 lynch
 
ryalaman said:
Mafia dumbtelling like that intentionally is, at best, something that we'd probably need to have a real conversation about. Winning is fun and all, but that is not an aboveboard play.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I sincerely apologize about my fuckup, fellas. It was intended as a placeholder and until I could get back and read the threads as I'd been working all afternoon, but it was unacceptable and def. changed the course of the game. Sorry again.
 
mako1331 said:
Yeah, I sincerely apologize about my fuckup, fellas. It was intended as a placeholder and until I could get back and read the threads as I'd been working all afternoon, but it was unacceptable and def. changed the course of the game. Sorry again.
Click to expand...

Lol, this is like game 2 for you - dont worry about it, it happens.

But dont ever fucking do it again.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top