Eagles_Legendz
Well-known member
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2011
- Messages
- 7,751
- Reaction score
- 366
Sorry dad, thanks for the 2 mafia kills.
i was a civ the last time this discussion happened too about mafia not using a strongman kill on me n1.
Sorry dad, thanks for the 2 mafia kills.
i'm pretty sure tim's mafia. there's nothing there - with numbers being more civ leaning to me, it makes his post i highlighted worse. definitely more in line with him floating through as mafia then his normal civ game.
Where else would I claim it? Have you been reading the role write ups for dead players? They all say it...
and why is forcing the cop out bad for mafia? what am I misunderstanding here
Close to cleared
20. JTP - gave us the 3 civs - yes
10. Toogs - one of the 3 civs - yes
8. Mako - one of the 3 civs, claims to be able to hand out a gun yes
11. SD3 - dead talker - not in this category
Civ lean
9. Rommy - looked good in the dv7 lynch more cleared than sd3
12. Townie - I don't think end of day with dv7 plays out like it did if both were mafia. Both gave out substantial information to try and save themselves. If both mafia, I think we would have seen more separation plays between the two and/or both just not giving info about their role and letting it play out. yes
3. Nonny - I think I've played a pretty civ game but I'll let you all decide that. eh
Claims, civ leaning
21. Knight - night invincible power claim - is in the ??? group to me, less spastic than normal when mafia but je ne sais pas
5. Redwing - watcher power claim, claims to know who protection is - teeny tiny bit civ leaning, could be mafia power
Others
1. Gouda should be here
2. Numbers - more civ leaning than to be in this category
13. Ryala should be here
18. JMan should be category above this
19. Timmay - probably mafia
Maf lean
16. Eaglez - maf lean, explanation #1106 - bad explanation, still like you
This is how I currently see the lay of the land. Have small leans within the others group but not enough to put something down. I still think Eaglez is the best play today unless someone can make a strong enough argument for on of the Others.
...did you read the rules? You PM the mod
He is saying that Mafia wouldn't want to use the strongman hit on him in case the cop came out early.
point of the strongman is to get around protection after an important role claims, not just yoloing into eagles n1. this came up last time and i was a civ too.
@Eagles -
Why the push back on SD3? You see that as a potential mafia play? Curious to hear your thought process there.
Somebody who is a part of Show of Hands should claim their damn power. I tried but I can't claim it twice unfortunately. RIP.
didn't sd3 just do that?