• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

Rush Mafia - Game Over - Rush Wins Again

Although with the roles we seem to have there may not be a traditional cop (or traditional anything for that matter)
 
I'm not down with the eagles logic. As your clearest civ, I'd probably rather have gouda or tim up
 
I've not gotten a consensus on who gets the gun. Jtp knows I'm a civ but that doesn't mean the other two are. Toogs?
 
TownieDeac said:
i don't understand redwing's logic re: eagles being maf just because he was protected

i don't understand the logic of thinking maf would use an unhittable kill on eagles d1, later days maybe, but also seems more well-suited to trying to kill a claimed power special

eagles was also instrumental in killing both dv7 and doofus

i don't see why he would be the play today for any reason other than "why is he still alive"
Click to expand...

So, on Day 2, there was only one person that visited Eagles. Could be investigation, could be protection, hard to say, but very likely a civ. Eagles wasn't killed, and didn't claim silenced or RB, typical reasons that mafia would visit someone. But you already said that Eagles has been a part of killing two mafia. As a civ, he is very dangerous to mafia. So the mafia would want to get rid of him as quickly as possible, potentially using a strongman hit to make sure. Otherwise, he is going to keep picking off mafia. That is why I leaned mafia on him. Certainly not a lock on Day 2, but it is curious.
 
redwing42 said:
So, on Day 2, there was only one person that visited Eagles. Could be investigation, could be protection, hard to say, but very likely a civ. Eagles wasn't killed, and didn't claim silenced or RB, typical reasons that mafia would visit someone. But you already said that Eagles has been a part of killing two mafia. As a civ, he is very dangerous to mafia. So the mafia would want to get rid of him as quickly as possible, potentially using a strongman hit to make sure. Otherwise, he is going to keep picking off mafia. That is why I leaned mafia on him. Certainly not a lock on Day 2, but it is curious.
Click to expand...

you leaned mafia on me when i had only been part of killing one mafia actually; doofus hadn't died yet.

point is still the same, yes i die early a lot of games as a civ; no mafia shouldn't be using a strongman kill on me n1.
 
Eagles_Legendz said:
flag ^^ post when i come back civ.
Click to expand...

I told doofus we should have used different posts. But for real, it's really lazy. I'm kinda suspicious of the hangers on there. It's not a reasonable conclusion that a strongman hit should have been used on an unclaimed eagles. He's not a cheat code.
 
mako1331 said:
I've not gotten a consensus on who gets the gun. Jtp knows I'm a civ but that doesn't mean the other two are. Toogs?
Click to expand...

JTP would have that information as mafia as well. He is definitely not cleared, and should never be trusted with a gun. Toogs is not entirely cleared either, but is a better choice. I'd offer to take it, but I'm not cleared either. I probably wouldn't use it anyway, unless we somehow got multiple mafia hits in one round.
 
ryalaman said:
I told doofus we should have used different posts. But for real, it's really lazy. I'm kinda suspicious of the hangers on there. It's not a reasonable conclusion that a strongman hit should have been used on an unclaimed eagles. He's not a cheat code.
Click to expand...

obviously i agree w/that but the post reads like you know i'm a civ and am likely to die here.
 
redwing42 said:
JTP would have that information as mafia as well. He is definitely not cleared, and should never be trusted with a gun. Toogs is not entirely cleared either, but is a better choice. I'd offer to take it, but I'm not cleared either. I probably wouldn't use it anyway, unless we somehow got multiple mafia hits in one round.
Click to expand...

Redwing, what is your full role, and who have you watched?
 
redwing42 said:
JTP would have that information as mafia as well. He is definitely not cleared, and should never be trusted with a gun. Toogs is not entirely cleared either, but is a better choice. I'd offer to take it, but I'm not cleared either. I probably wouldn't use it anyway, unless we somehow got multiple mafia hits in one round.
Click to expand...

don't listen to this well reasoned post

give it to me so I shove gouda's shit in.
 
Vote Count as of Post #1215

Eagles (4) - Nonny, Tim, SD3, JMan
Tim (3) - Gouda, Eagles, Mako
Gouda (2) - Numbers, JTP
Numbers (1) - Townie

YTV- Redwing, Rommy, Toogs, Ryala, Knight

Vote or die: Ryala, Toogs
 
AnonymousDeac said:
Eagles started the momentum for the lynch on townie day 1 which made him look pretty clear.
Mafia has a strongman hit.
Mafia doesn't use strongman hit on an eagles that is pretty civ looking.

Not hitting Eagles often comes down to 1) he does something that is likely to get him lynched or 2) mafia is scared of protection or being watched. Neither of those two are applicable for night 1, when the chance civs got that power was very rare and they had a strongman hit.

This is not a good look for Eagles and enough for me to vote for him.

***Eagles***
Click to expand...

Going back through, this one is sending up some tingles. Nonny was around, posted with a bunch of reads from last night w/o any eagles mention and then chipped in this word salad after gouda led on eagles.
 
in summary, toogs is the best choice

but I'm a better choice because I'll fucking use that bitch YOLO
 
Eagles_Legendz said:
you leaned mafia on me when i had only been part of killing one mafia actually; doofus hadn't died yet.

point is still the same, yes i die early a lot of games as a civ; no mafia shouldn't be using a strongman kill on me n1.
Click to expand...

Kind of ran my thoughts together there, but I was saying that you were involved with killing two mafia as reasoning for why mafia would want you dead in a general sense, since Townie didn't seem to understand that you are good at this game. It was not a factor in my lean at the time. Your hesitation to finally vote for Deacsfan27 at the end of last round is an additional factor, but that wasn't part of the initial read.
 
i would rather kill gouda than eagles. gouda has been low key dikriding eagles all game, can't imagine he would do that if teammates.

***gouda***
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top