• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

ABC Mafia; Civs Fall Just Short; Da, bym, Townie, toogs, parlay Mafia Win!

AnonymousDeac said:
Picked up on a few things but nothing major.

Toogs' anger isn't alignment indicative. Don't love GAT's play but I lean civ. WFU is a fine policy lynch but he's likely not mafia.

Manning starting a vote on gouda but moving over to WFU after the entry is notable (after juice put a 2nd on gouda). If Gouda or Manning show up mafia, will be looking at the other as a teammate.


@Juice - why sd3?
Click to expand...

JuiceCrewAllStar said:
no strong reason -- he and GAT were my two options for the tie

gut instinct that SD3 would be a chosen mafia due to his frequent endgame appearances
Click to expand...

Nonny had the same feeling, Juice's response is mediocre at best.
 
JuiceCrewAllStar said:
have tejas or jtp surfaced?
Click to expand...

In the midst of the game this post could easily be overlooked, but when reading through it stuck out like a sore thumb. Its that post where you are trying to be observant and helpful, but really not saying shit.
 
Toogs said:
who put that maj on sd3? Bet that was saving mafia if either tejas or jtp are.
Click to expand...

My argument is that Juice's post was really the post that pushed the majo. Made sure to let it be known that neither had posted, but didnt have the trail of voting to prevent the majo.

If tejas or JTP is dirty, Id put money juice is with them.
 
Other quick thoughts from catching up. That was extremely selfish by SD3, I may see what he was trying to do, but I honestly think he just wanted to not go in day one or be the hero.

His move could have maybe helped the civs if he didn't do two things, 1. reveal so late and 2. tell folks to move to GAT.

He basically eliminated any chance that we could hav made reads from reactions and vote switches. You wait so late and then tell people to move to a player, what are you going to learn from that point?
 
I think parlay's reappearance at the open of day 2 looks off. I don't by the tone from Parlay there after what was revealed about SD3.

And I'm trying to figure out if Parlay is devious enough that after coming off a game he wrote that was so involved and required reading rules and instructions carefully and led to a significant discussion of dumbtelling, he would then come out and triple down on dumbtelling regarding the cop in this game?
 
All that to say

***juice***

See you fools in the morning.
 
This is good

I'll ride

***juice***
 
Good stuff duff. I admittedly haven’t been paying to close of attention but I recall seeing that jtp/tejas post from juice and going hmmmm

***switch to juice***
 
Mafia-ish
1. gouda
12. Da
16. Townie

Could see them being mafia
3. Juice
5. toogs
8. mako
17. rommy

Don't think they're mafia
6. Tejas
10. WFU
14. parlay

Have no idea
2. bym
4. Duff
7. JTP
15. jhawk
19. Nonny

Let's start with the list at the top.

***gouda***
 
Duffterp said:
My argument is that Juice's post was really the post that pushed the majo. Made sure to let it be known that neither had posted, but didnt have the trail of voting to prevent the majo.

If tejas or JTP is dirty, Id put money juice is with them.
Click to expand...

I come to different conclusions on the same information. Townie is the one who caused the majo and saved Tejas and JTP.

***Townie***
 
I’ll go townie over Gouda if it comes to that
 
WFU03 said:
Mafia-ish
1. gouda
12. Da
16. Townie

Could see them being mafia
3. Juice
5. toogs
8. mako
17. rommy

Don't think they're mafia
6. Tejas
10. WFU
14. parlay

Have no idea
2. bym
4. Duff
7. JTP
15. jhawk
19. Nonny

Let's start with the list at the top.

***gouda***
Click to expand...

Quick question, why do you think Tejas isnt maf? Would think he'd be in the no idea list with JTP and myself given the absences yesterday.
 
bym051d said:
I come to different conclusions on the same information. Townie is the one who caused the majo and saved Tejas and JTP.

***Townie***
Click to expand...

Fair enough, you look at the person pulling the trigger, I'm looking at the person giving the gun.
 
WFU03 said:
Mafia-ish
1. gouda
12. Da
16. Townie

Could see them being mafia
3. Juice
5. toogs
8. mako
17. rommy

Don't think they're mafia
6. Tejas
10. WFU
14. parlay

Have no idea
2. bym
4. Duff
7. JTP
15. jhawk
19. Nonny

Let's start with the list at the top.

***gouda***
Click to expand...

This list is definitely something
 
This is a dumb line of thinking.

Unless tejas is mafia

Tejas are you mafia
 
I think it's be smarter to lynch tejas and then look at people who may have saved him with a majority

But.

That's also dumb because gouda is definitely mafia.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top