• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

Cold War Spy Mafia Game Thread: GAME OVER CIVS WIN

Gaterrapin said:
Tell this to dv7
Click to expand...

holeeeee shit

again, I had you as a heavy civ lean


but you saying you were more clear than rommy/manning/bym/redwing/myself was fucking insane. That was a block of 5 tied together vs you and your posts/moscow chatzy comments.


Stop being so obtuse.
 
There were a lot of interesting ideas. But there needed to be vanilla civs, fewer civ jobs, and/or more recruitables to keep it from being a claim off. The game was basically, "Are you mafia?" "No. I'm the farmer." "Oh I'm a farmer too." "Cool. I'm a factory worker." The role reveals made it clear what claims were legit and how few people could be recruited.

PhDeac said:
The way I see it, the game is almost broken open. Redwing, GM, d14, jtp, GAT, and SD3 are the only ones who haven't claimed. One is the British mafia, two are Indys, one is the Soviet farmer, one is the British politician. One is probably the Soviet vanilla.
Click to expand...

I didn't make a night move because it was clear my only shot at winning was to replace one of the worker roles with my silent kill. And I wanted better odds to avoid investigating or hitting an anti-town.
 
I was Nate and Charlie, both were me very briefly checking in to see if there was anything worth while going on. I basically abandoned the chats Sunday night.
 
Gooner said:
FUCK JHAWK WE ARE MORTAL ENEMIES NOW
Click to expand...

HAHAHAHA BOOM!

giphy.gif
 
Who killed me and why? Y’all could’ve swayed the hell out of me. I was a goddamn babe in the woods
 



jhawk and gooner getting guns in mafia
 
Jhawk admitting he was recruitable in cafe and killing gooner with a faulty weapon were the best two parts of this game
 
mako1331 said:
Who killed me and why? Y’all could’ve swayed the hell out of me. I was a goddamn babe in the woods
Click to expand...

I hit you. At that point you were one of the few that had an absolutely unassailable claim as a farmer/factory worker. There was no way to win the game with you still in it. I guess if you're saying I should have hit Gat instead and tricked you into a mislynch that's fair, but I know the joy you get from being night hit
 
Fun game, I didnt do a good job in my role. I think this is the case of reading everything that is states before jumping into the game. I was offline all weekend so when I finally got online Sunday evening I kinda rushed into the game.

Recruited: PH, Mako and then Gooner. By the night 2 recruitment, I had a good handle on the chats and who was what, too bad that gooner was already recruited and I died day 3.

I started trying to mess around in both chats with truths and misinformation and wasnt paying close attention to the thread. I checked and saw I was in a 3 way tie and panicked to move my vote onto one of the people I was tied with. I should have held my vote to the buzzer and I know I would have had a successful recruitment of JTP, I could have then died the next day for the vote switch and still kept my faction alive.

But I really liked the idea behind the 2 chatzys and how to manipulate them for benefit. I just didnt do that until it was too late.
 
deacon14 said:
I hit you. At that point you were one of the few that had an absolutely unassailable claim as a farmer/factory worker. There was no way to win the game with you still in it. I guess if you're saying I should have hit Gat instead and tricked you into a mislynch that's fair, but I know the joy you get from being night hit
Click to expand...

You’re a sweet, sweet boy.
 
Also to GAT, i mentioned in the thread but working out the factions as you did was a basic menu of who the mafia should NOT recruit. Thats what I was pointing out during the game.
 
DeacdeTejas said:
Jhawk admitting he was recruitable in cafe and killing gooner with a faulty weapon were the best two parts of this game
Click to expand...

the first part was really dumb by me but I thought about it and thought it was fun to just go with it and see what happens
 
bym051d said:
I think GAT viewed it best as “there’s no way a role exists that can win the game by getting lynched on D1.”
Click to expand...

Most times that role has an independent win condition, I don’t know that I’ve seen it in big games where it ends when they get voted out. rom can check me on that though
 
Duffterp said:
Fun game, I didnt do a good job in my role. I think this is the case of reading everything that is states before jumping into the game. I was offline all weekend so when I finally got online Sunday evening I kinda rushed into the game.

Recruited: PH, Mako and then Gooner. By the night 2 recruitment, I had a good handle on the chats and who was what, too bad that gooner was already recruited and I died day 3.

I started trying to mess around in both chats with truths and misinformation and wasnt paying close attention to the thread. I checked and saw I was in a 3 way tie and panicked to move my vote onto one of the people I was tied with. I should have held my vote to the buzzer and I know I would have had a successful recruitment of JTP, I could have then died the next day for the vote switch and still kept my faction alive.

But I really liked the idea behind the 2 chatzys and how to manipulate them for benefit. I just didnt do that until it was too late.
Click to expand...

I kinda wish I had taken more of your approach and paid attention to the chatzys. Gooner and I had a conversation early on that there didn't seem to be much to gain from being in there, so we stopped going, but I think that may have been the wrong approach.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top