deaconson
Exhausted
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2011
- Messages
- 24,354
- Reaction score
- 7,945
Call and Oats BABY
Call and Oats BABY
Because you’re high.My 5 year old picked The Giving Tree to read at bedtime tonight. Usually that book gets me all sappy and emotional but tonight I realized the boy in the book is just dumb as shit. Like why would you walk up to a tree and say “can you give me money”
My 5 year old picked The Giving Tree to read at bedtime tonight. Usually that book gets me all sappy and emotional but tonight I realized the boy in the book is just dumb as shit. Like why would you walk up to a tree and say “can you give me money”
There are some good reads pushing back on the message of The Giving Tree.My 5 year old picked The Giving Tree to read at bedtime tonight. Usually that book gets me all sappy and emotional but tonight I realized the boy in the book is just dumb as shit. Like why would you walk up to a tree and say “can you give me money”
If you ask parents to think of a children’s book about generosity, “The Giving Tree” is usually the first — and often the only — one they can name. But here’s the thing: It’s not really about generosity. It’s a book about self-sacrifice — and those are two very different things.
To some readers, the tree’s act of sacrifice seems noble, like the unconditional love a parent gives to a child. But if you assume the story is about generosity, it’s easy to learn the wrong lessons: that it’s O.K. for a child to take selfishly, and that adults should give until it hurts — and keep giving until they literally have nothing left to offer. That’s a recipe for trouble.
We don’t know what motivated Shel Silverstein to write “The Giving Tree.” In a rare interview, he said it was about “a relationship between two people; one gives and the other takes.” But we think it’s best read as a cautionary tale about love. Although the tree seems to take joy in giving to the boy, their relationship is entirely one-sided. The tree is perfectly happy to destroy herself under the guise of “love” for the boy. That’s not love; it’s abuse. Even an editor of the book, Phyllis Fogelman, felt that way. “I have had qualms about my part in the publication of ‘The Giving Tree,’ which conveys a message with which I don’t agree,” she said in an interview. “I think it is basically a book about a sadomasochistic relationship.”
If you take the book at face value, you’re missing the point. If you finish reading it to your children and then just close the book and say good night, you’re doing them a disservice. If you praise the tree — “she really loved the boy” — you’re teaching them the wrong lesson. Instead, this book should be used as a starting point for conversations about healthy behavior and healthy relationships.
More like the grifting tree
Awesome. Lots of good shit. Dishoom the best Indian food I’ve had outside India. Boxpark is a fun place to get drinks/play cards/get some food. Brick Lane some of the best vintage shopping in the world.@TownieDeac booked a place in shoreditch. Good looking out.
I literally cannot love this post enough@Kory put on Music Has the Right to Children while I put my 2 year old to sleep
99% of the time he listens to Baby Beluga by Raffi or Do You Wanna Build a Snowman from Frozen on repeat til he’s asleep but tonight he asked for a “NEW SONG DAD”
And then every time I thought he was asleep, for like 40 straight min, I’d turn the music off and get up to leave the room and he’d wake up and say “noooo more funny music dad!!!!”
On Its Way to USPS
Departed Shipping Partner Facility, USPS Awaiting Item
MEBANE, NC 27302
May 22, 2023, 3:29 am
Shipping Partner: AMAZON
I’ve had that happen lately. Usually it means I’ll get from USPS next day. Sometimes the USPS won’t even say it’s out for delivery.I have a package coming that I need before leaving for the beach this weekend, it left a facility in Mebane (25 miles from my house) yesterday morning at 3 AM and that is the last update, no idea where it is now. So annoying.