QT4KU
Well-known member
- Joined
- Oct 9, 2011
- Messages
- 1,105
- Reaction score
- 95
bym051d- Confuses me. Always. It’s almost like he’s the deac version of tic. Except I can usually read tic. That said he hasn't really jumped out at me as clearly mafia this game. But I can't clear him either.
DV7- has tried to guide the game several times but been shut down and backed off. The backing off part is interesting to me. Seems like something mafia might do when they think they’re crossing a line. Has been consistent with his list of 3 quiets and wanting to kill them. If all three flip civ, he jumps to my top choice for mafia. Kill the quiets is always an easy and effective push and he seems to be carrying the torch and waving it wildly.
Tejas- Is my most civ read at this point. I’ve felt this way in two games. One he was a civ. The other I died fairly early and he was mafia. I’m sticking with civ for now.
lokisapocalypse- Yeah. So about loki. His roleblock is an absurd choice from what I can tell and what everyone else seems to be saying. This completely eliminates him from whatever mafia the roleblocker is in for me. Not seeing him as the teammate I’d pick to roleblock and try to pass off as a civ. He hasn’t really done anything else to look sketchy and based on the previous statement, the sketchiest thing about him wasn’t his fault.
jtp- again, I always think he is mafia. He’s posted a bit more overnight but still nothing of substance really. Some theories here and there but nothing more. It’s mostly responding to comments and not a ton of analysis. But the vig hit, unless countered at some point, has to clear him.
Eagles- has seemed like a weirdo the entire game. I felt fairly certain he was mafia. However, this I’m out for the day stuff isn’t really an eagles mafia move. It’s kind of a dick move that he would be annoyed by… So he’s not off my list but he isn’t the top of the list at the moment either. Yes. I am aware this is a fairly opposing stance to yesterday.
Boston- not a clue but the vote on texas for zero reason was pretty terrible. If mafia, he and sd3 are most likely not on the same mafia. With small numbers you can’t bank on two silent players making it to the end game. Same logic applies to me being mafia with either Boston or sd3.
damo- mafia damo allllllways trips up. I see lots of votes for him from various people but I haven’t seen mafia damo yet.
sd3- Of the quiets, he’s my vote for mafia. Granted he’s one of those that always seems like mafia because of his posting style. Even when he’s gone through and bulk-quoted there doesn’t appear to be much there.
Gooner- Take charge and boss people around mini-rommy gooner always worries me. His day one push for someone to kill tic really annoys me and bothers me and makes me want to kill him. He is on my suspect mafia list but not at the top. And if he ever refers to me being on a leash again, I will do more than kill him.
RHTB&G (Raise)- Raise hasn’t played his typical civ game but I should note it’s been a long time since I’ve played with him. My feelings on him are mostly tied to eagles at this point… Not sure he’s my top suspect at this point as really the only thing I have to go on is eagles. Which I’m currently wavering on out of confusion.
Toogs- reasonably calm and disinterested toogs isn’t normally mafia toogs. He hasn’t done much to make me think he is a civ but he hasn’t done anything at all to make me think he is mafia thus far. I might be trying too hard to compensate for the bias that he’s a sub… So I might be failing to see things that I otherwise might notice because I don’t want that to impact my thoughts. That said, I just don’t read him as mafia as of now.
Deacsfan27- I can’t say I’ve really noticed him all that much during the read through. Hiding in plain sight maybe? Not sure I cared for his interaction with eagles after his vote on eagles though. Fairly ok with the idea that they aren’t on the same mafia. Probably ahead of gooner on my list.
Of the quiets- QT, sd3, Boston- If I had to rank this group, as I said before, I’d pick sd3 over Boston and myself. I know my role. Boston is doing nothing helpful or unhelpful at all. If he was mafia you’d think he would be putting in at least some effort. To try to appear civ or to cause confusion. Like sd3 is probably doing.
sd3
DV7- has tried to guide the game several times but been shut down and backed off. The backing off part is interesting to me. Seems like something mafia might do when they think they’re crossing a line. Has been consistent with his list of 3 quiets and wanting to kill them. If all three flip civ, he jumps to my top choice for mafia. Kill the quiets is always an easy and effective push and he seems to be carrying the torch and waving it wildly.
Tejas- Is my most civ read at this point. I’ve felt this way in two games. One he was a civ. The other I died fairly early and he was mafia. I’m sticking with civ for now.
lokisapocalypse- Yeah. So about loki. His roleblock is an absurd choice from what I can tell and what everyone else seems to be saying. This completely eliminates him from whatever mafia the roleblocker is in for me. Not seeing him as the teammate I’d pick to roleblock and try to pass off as a civ. He hasn’t really done anything else to look sketchy and based on the previous statement, the sketchiest thing about him wasn’t his fault.
jtp- again, I always think he is mafia. He’s posted a bit more overnight but still nothing of substance really. Some theories here and there but nothing more. It’s mostly responding to comments and not a ton of analysis. But the vig hit, unless countered at some point, has to clear him.
Eagles- has seemed like a weirdo the entire game. I felt fairly certain he was mafia. However, this I’m out for the day stuff isn’t really an eagles mafia move. It’s kind of a dick move that he would be annoyed by… So he’s not off my list but he isn’t the top of the list at the moment either. Yes. I am aware this is a fairly opposing stance to yesterday.
Boston- not a clue but the vote on texas for zero reason was pretty terrible. If mafia, he and sd3 are most likely not on the same mafia. With small numbers you can’t bank on two silent players making it to the end game. Same logic applies to me being mafia with either Boston or sd3.
damo- mafia damo allllllways trips up. I see lots of votes for him from various people but I haven’t seen mafia damo yet.
sd3- Of the quiets, he’s my vote for mafia. Granted he’s one of those that always seems like mafia because of his posting style. Even when he’s gone through and bulk-quoted there doesn’t appear to be much there.
Gooner- Take charge and boss people around mini-rommy gooner always worries me. His day one push for someone to kill tic really annoys me and bothers me and makes me want to kill him. He is on my suspect mafia list but not at the top. And if he ever refers to me being on a leash again, I will do more than kill him.
RHTB&G (Raise)- Raise hasn’t played his typical civ game but I should note it’s been a long time since I’ve played with him. My feelings on him are mostly tied to eagles at this point… Not sure he’s my top suspect at this point as really the only thing I have to go on is eagles. Which I’m currently wavering on out of confusion.
Toogs- reasonably calm and disinterested toogs isn’t normally mafia toogs. He hasn’t done much to make me think he is a civ but he hasn’t done anything at all to make me think he is mafia thus far. I might be trying too hard to compensate for the bias that he’s a sub… So I might be failing to see things that I otherwise might notice because I don’t want that to impact my thoughts. That said, I just don’t read him as mafia as of now.
Deacsfan27- I can’t say I’ve really noticed him all that much during the read through. Hiding in plain sight maybe? Not sure I cared for his interaction with eagles after his vote on eagles though. Fairly ok with the idea that they aren’t on the same mafia. Probably ahead of gooner on my list.
Of the quiets- QT, sd3, Boston- If I had to rank this group, as I said before, I’d pick sd3 over Boston and myself. I know my role. Boston is doing nothing helpful or unhelpful at all. If he was mafia you’d think he would be putting in at least some effort. To try to appear civ or to cause confusion. Like sd3 is probably doing.
sd3
