Feel free to let me know if any of the info below is incorrect.
Top 10 RSCI rankings since 2005:
Number of All-Star appearances in ()
Not currently signed to an NBA team in bold
2005
1. Josh McRoberts (0)
2. Monta Ellis (0)
3. Martell Webster (0)
4. Tyler Hansbrough (0)
5. Louis Williams (0)
6. Julian Wright (0)
7. Richard Hendrix (0)
8. Tasmin Mitchell (0)
9. Mario Chalmers (0)
10. Andrew Bynum (1)
2006
1. Greg Oden (0)
2. Kevin Durant (6)
3. Brandan Wright (0)
4. Spencer Hawes (0)
5. Ty Lawson (0)
6. Thaddeus Young (0)
7. Chase Budinger (0)
8. Wayne Ellington (0)
9. Brook Lopez (1)
10. Gerald Henderson (0)
2007
1. OJ Mayo (0)
2. Kevin Love (3)
3. Eric Gordon (0)
4. Michael Beasley (0)
5. Derrick Rose (3)
6. Kyle Singler (0)
7. Jerryd Bayless (0)
8. Donte Greene (0)
9. J.J. Hickson (0)
10. Patrick Patterson (0)
2008
1. Brandon Jennings (0)
2. Jrue Holiday (1)
3. Tyreke Evans (0)
4. Samardo Samuels (0)
5. DeMar DeRozan (1)
6. Greg Monroe (0)
7. Al-Farouq Aminu (0)
8. Byron Mullens (0)
9. Ed Davis (0)
10. Delvon Roe (0)
2009
1. Derrick Favors (0)
2. John Wall (2)
3. DeMarcus Cousins (1)
4. Avery Bradley (0)
5. John Henson (0)
6. Xavier Henry (0)
7. Renardo Sidney (0)
8. Lance Stephenson (0)
9. Kenny Boynton (0)
10. Keith Gallon (0)
2010
1. Harrison Barnes (0)
2. Kyrie Irving (3)
3. Jared Sullinger (0)
4. Brandon Knight (0)
5. Tobias Harris (0)
6. Josh Selby (0)
7. Enes Kanter (0)
8. Perry Jones (0)
9. Tristan Thompson (0)
10. Will Barton (0)
2011
1. Anthony Davis (2)
2. Austin Rivers (0)
3. Michael Kidd-Gilchrist (0)
4. Bradley Beal (0)
5. Quincy Miller (0)
6. James Michael McAdoo (0)
7. Marquis Teague (0)
8. Le'Bryan Nash (0)
9. Adonis Thomas (0)
10. Cody Zeller (0)
2012
1. Nerlens Noel (0)
2. Shabazz Muhammad (0)
3. Isaiah Austin (0)
4. Kyle Anderson (0)
5. Steven Adams (0)
6. Anthony Bennett (0)
7. Kaleb Tarczewski (0)
8. Alex Poythress (0)
9. Marcus Smart (0)
10. Archie Goodwin (0)
I'll cut it off there since the 2013 class were rookies last year, and none of them made the All-Star team.
This expectation that any old Burger Boy under GOOD COACHING should have a good chance to be an All-Star in the NBA is really misguided. A reasonable, well-thought-out rebuttal to that argument would be appreciated, but it'll probably be the usual Creamy/Townie type "Ayo, you're awful, you suck, #badfan, YOU'RE RUINING THE VIBES." Meh, whatevs, fellas.