As the two explained it, the Heat's core and Paul had several conversations about how such a team would work. This was likely in 2011, the offseason after James' and Bosh's first season in Miami and when Paul was up for a trade from the
New Orleans Hornets.
The group supposedly reached an agreement, until someone — later identified as Paul's brother, CJ —asked a very important question. The scene,
as Wade recalled it:
"We talk about all this — who gonna have the ball, we can all play together, CP, I can play off the ball — we figured all that out. Then somebody said, 'Well, who gonna wear No. 3?'
"Silence. Messed the whole trade up because CP couldn't wear No. 3 in Miami."
At the time, Wade and Paul were both perennial All-Stars, though Wade, who is four years older, was the more established player and had won an NBA championship in 2006. It sounds almost unbelievable that either player — but especially Paul — would give up a chance to form an unprecedentedly stacked team, but then the two veterans revived the argument on the podcast:
Paul: "I don't know what they was going to do. Because you was older, you probably could have just worn 33."
Wade: "No, no. I wasn't older."
Paul: "You was older than me."
Wade: "I was in my prime!"
Paul: "I know, but because you was older than me, you probably just wear 33."
Wade: "No, no, no. See, this is the conversation we're having, and I'm like ,'That's my number.' He's like, 'Well, that's my number.'"
Wade firmly stated that Heat president Pat Riley declined to pull the trigger on the trade due to the jersey number, then noted that he had already sacrificed quite a bit to form the Heat's super team.
"Listen, I sacrificed not getting touches. I sacrificed not getting articles read and not getting the most money, but I am not giving up my number!"