cville deac
Well-known member
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2011
- Messages
- 15,279
- Reaction score
- 919
I don't know why we all can't agree that Buzzdick is lousy at every aspect of his job and that Dino wasn't a good coach who was going to get fired sooner or later and whose last recruiting class looked good on paper at the time but turned out to be incredibly overrated.
Let's not be revisionist historians. We were all jazzed up about Dino's last class at the time. Then Dino is fired, and there is a dispute as to the reasons. Then we fans wanted that class kept together under the new coach, and Wellman apparently wanted the same thing, and Buzzdick ended up retaining Dino's assistants and entire class. Then we're historically bad for 2 years and have player scandals thrown in. McKie turns out to be the only legit ACC talent out of the bunch, though Desrosiers and Chennault would certainly be getting meaningful minutes on this current roster if they were still here. And that Tabb was recruited to campus by Dino and was given 3rd and 4th chances by Buzzdick is an indictment of both.
Now to Buzzdick's recruiting. His 1st class is historically awful, and I'm sure glad that after Buzzdick arrived on the scene we went after Fischer and cooled on Larkin (or Larkin wisely cooled on us). Brilliant. Then he has a large solid class that includes 2 ACC caliber starters in CMM and Thomas and some role players. Then he has what looks to be a poor 3rd class - jury is out on whether McClinton can play, but Overton doesn't strike me as an ACC talent. Then he has what will probably be a poor 4th class, landing a potentially legit PG but completely striking out on big men when he loses a decommit. Bob Staak would be embarrassed by that 4 year haul. Had he put this group together in the ACC olden days of 10-20 (or 30 or 40) years ago, they'd have struggled winning 1-2 ACC games a year. The reason we're gonna win 6-7 ACC games is Johnson is recruiting way worse with Eddie and the Walk-ons, and Brownell, Donohue and Gregory are recruiting just as poorly, Brey lost his star, and Turgeon, Roy and Gottfried ain't setting any worlds on fire.
So can we just agree Dino wasn't a good overall coach and Buzzdick is terrible at every facet of his job?
Let's not be revisionist historians. We were all jazzed up about Dino's last class at the time. Then Dino is fired, and there is a dispute as to the reasons. Then we fans wanted that class kept together under the new coach, and Wellman apparently wanted the same thing, and Buzzdick ended up retaining Dino's assistants and entire class. Then we're historically bad for 2 years and have player scandals thrown in. McKie turns out to be the only legit ACC talent out of the bunch, though Desrosiers and Chennault would certainly be getting meaningful minutes on this current roster if they were still here. And that Tabb was recruited to campus by Dino and was given 3rd and 4th chances by Buzzdick is an indictment of both.
Now to Buzzdick's recruiting. His 1st class is historically awful, and I'm sure glad that after Buzzdick arrived on the scene we went after Fischer and cooled on Larkin (or Larkin wisely cooled on us). Brilliant. Then he has a large solid class that includes 2 ACC caliber starters in CMM and Thomas and some role players. Then he has what looks to be a poor 3rd class - jury is out on whether McClinton can play, but Overton doesn't strike me as an ACC talent. Then he has what will probably be a poor 4th class, landing a potentially legit PG but completely striking out on big men when he loses a decommit. Bob Staak would be embarrassed by that 4 year haul. Had he put this group together in the ACC olden days of 10-20 (or 30 or 40) years ago, they'd have struggled winning 1-2 ACC games a year. The reason we're gonna win 6-7 ACC games is Johnson is recruiting way worse with Eddie and the Walk-ons, and Brownell, Donohue and Gregory are recruiting just as poorly, Brey lost his star, and Turgeon, Roy and Gottfried ain't setting any worlds on fire.
So can we just agree Dino wasn't a good overall coach and Buzzdick is terrible at every facet of his job?