I like one of Jman/Duff/Numbers here.
Duff came into the game with his first "real" post to break a 3 way tie by putting Knight up 1 when it was Knight/Ph/Numbers all tied at 3. He made a throwaway vote saying he was going to struggle to catch up to the thread and then placed the go-ahead on Knight.
From there, you can extrapolate it was to give help to one of Numbers/Ph or both, but with Ph's softclaim, that should keep him off the block for the time being.
So if Duff = Mafia, then Numbers = likely mafia?
Then, with Jman's follow vote on Duff this round with me, and Duff & Jman's interactions about it, we have a lot to go on with one of these three. Discuss.