Late week mafia- Game Over- Mafia Wins

[JManslow]

vote count through #131

Knight/GTB(4)WFU03BYMDeacsfan27Rommy
Deacsfan27(4)TownieJmanKnightDamo
Townie(3)GoonerTejasGAT
WFU03(1)Gouda
Rommy(1)Juice

Count before Knight’s claim. Juice and Tejas look the worst to me here. Juice especially with his vote hanging.

If you think I might be mafia you’d have to think we stacked 3 on a civ. Highly unlikely but I guess it’s possible.

 

[JManslow]

I have 03 and gooner as mentally cleared. Gonna do a reread tonight so I’ll have more thoughts then

 

[romanovKU]

I have 03 and gooner as mentally cleared. Gonna do a reread tonight so I’ll have more thoughts then

Thoughts on tejas’s “???” Post at the end of d1

 

[JManslow]

I think there's a nonzero chance the mafia is knight, damo, and rommy though


real cop has to come out now if knight is lying because that would give us a wealth of information going in to day 3

Not a great post here

 

[JManslow]

Thoughts on tejas’s “???” Post at the end of d1

I don’t really think much of it one way or another. I tried to look for context behind it and it just seems meh. If anything i tend to consider rapid responses like that as civ. When I’m mafia I’m always careful about what I say, especially near a deadline like that.

 

[Gooner]

I think it's super duper funny that Knight rolled damo as a maf teammate and was like "fuck I'm going to have to run interference from page 1 on him to get him through to day 2."

 

[Gooner]

This is a bad switch.

I just saw the vote count. In what world am I a day 1 lynch? Did no one read last game?

lol

 

[Gooner]

The Knight fake-anger at Tejas seems manufactured as fuck on pages 6 and 7

 

[JManslow]

Me asking a question does not indicate my understanding of the answer. In this game, the answer of the player matters more than my understanding of the situation.

How the hell did you get this so wrong? I asked Doofus why he thought he was an easy kill because that is exactly something that mafia says. I wanted his answer to shed light on that.

I don't fucking ask questions in this game to get an answer to the question, I ask the question to get their answer.

Tejas, were you dropped on your head as a child?

Yeah this reads as scripted

 

[Gooner]

The Knight fake-anger at Tejas seems manufactured as fuck on pages 6 and 7

By this I mean that it reads super separation-y now knowing that Knight is mafia

 

[Gooner]

Deacsfan27 (4) Townie Jman Knight Damo

you can't let df27 die when the other 2 options are voting for df27. probability says one of the two voting for df27 is maf

this was a decent pull, props romalom

 

[Deacsfan27]

Also probably clears Jman. No way they were all on me

 

[DeacdeTejas]

I just finished a workout at home and feel like shit.

 

[Gooner]

Through #150

Knight (4) - WFU03, BYM, DF27, Rommy,
Deacsfan27 (4) - Townie, Jman, Knight, damo
Townie (3) - Gooner, Tejas, GAT
WFU03 - Gouda
Rommy - Juice

5 minutes left

This was the vote count right after Knight's cop claim, no one had switched yet.

With 2 people already on doofus to try and save Knight, I would find it incredibly hard to believe that all 3 do that on D1 to save a teammate. It's possible sure, but would be super risky if Knight just gets lynched there. So that makes me lean JMan slightly civ.

It's also incredibly hard to believe that any mafia teammate would be on Knight there when there were two other perfectly viable lynch candidates in Townie. Any teammate may get some heat for switching away, but definitely buys Knight an extra round and they might luckbox the cop without having to claim it out. Lean WFU & bym civ for this.

That leaves Tejas and Juice. Lynch in some order. I prefer Tejas for actual mafia reasons but Juice for "we have nothing to go on and if we are wrong today and it's not Juice, that's a problem" reasons is also a good vote.

***Tejas***

 

[WFU03]

What about Gooner? Shouldn’t he be in the same category as Tejas?

 

[DeacdeTejas]

2. Gooner
3. BYM
4. Tejas
6. Rommy - civ
7. WFU03
8. Jman
11. Juice
12. deacsfan27 - civ cop

It’s 7-1 so we have 3 shots at this and there are 6 ?s

Goal for the next 16 hours is to find 3 civs.

I would rank them in (most mafia to least mafia):

Juice - bleh
Gooner - mostly because I think your decent enough to pull off getting this far and I cant find anything egregious
03 - had some decent interaction with knight and damo
Jman - i doubt all of mafia end up in voting block together on day 1, but at the same time its knight and he was probably belligerent in chatzy
Bym - i just dont think bym does the damo dumbtell stuff over and over again as mafia
Tejas

 

[bym051d]

I think it's super duper funny that Knight rolled damo as a maf teammate and was like "fuck I'm going to have to run interference from page 1 on him to get him through to day 2."

I wonder about the Damo hit on Doof/Gouda. I wonder if they really thought there was heat on Damo after Knight flipped mafia.

I would’ve thought Knight flipping mafia would have cleared Damo in most people’s mind.

Maybe the Doofus discussion about wanting to know if Damo was dirty at the end of the round made them question it.

 

[JManslow]

What about Gooner? Shouldn’t he be in the same category as Tejas?

Gooner’s tone and work read as civ to me but I could be wrong. I think it’s Juice/Tejas as 1a/1b and Gooner after that.

 

[bym051d]

Gooner’s tone and work read as civ to me but I could be wrong. I think it’s Juice/Tejas as 1a/1b and Gooner after that.

I would agree. If Gooner’s dirty, he’s playing it well. He’d be playing his cards right for a coveted Top 6 Ranking in the Official Gaterrapin’ Mafia Writers’ Poll.

 

[Gooner]

What about Gooner? Shouldn’t he be in the same category as Tejas?

I don't know if this is directed at me and I normally don't read myself because it's dumb, I'm going to be right 100% of the time, but I literally was the post that got Knight to fake claim cop. Go look, he quoted it when he did it. I had promised to vote Knight over doofus no matter what, meaning 2 other people would have to vote doofus when 2 maf teammates were already on him. It's not clearing, but that should at the very least put me behind a few people in line.