• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

Better Call Saul, The Mafia Game. Indies Win! Gooner, GAT and Duff

DaDeacs said:
He also had votes on bym and DV7, for whatever credit you give that. Just feel like there are better options. Unless you know something I dont.
Click to expand...

Honestly like I mentioned I dont give Boston credit for teh bym vote.

That happened after the rommy AA, but before my reveal. He had to put his vote somewhere and I was pretty far out in the lead so there was no reason to think I would not go at that point without a claim. So why not put it on a teammate. He had no reason to believe at that point that:

A. I would claim
B. votes would move to Bym

IF that happened after my claim or he was 2nd or 3rd on Bym, I would be much more sold on him. Thats my read of it.

I also recall the whole backup cop talk, Boston brought it up and the next mention of a back up cop came from bym the next morning. Just small things like that when you already suspect someone pushed me to vote for him.
 
If Saul is the indy Kim is definitely helping him in some way, rough for Duff.
 
TownieDeac said:
i don't think i'm going to vote for tejas. being exceptionally wrong all game is a fairly civ trait in my book.
Click to expand...

This is an extremely questionable way to approach the game
 
Still trying to figure out the deacon14 bribe thing. If we assume gouda bribed him night one, means he is not whatever mafia gouda is. But, he also wasn't told it was a banker and Juice was.

I am guessing the reasoning deacon14 was not told is either he is the other mafia or has no role or thing or whatever that can be bribed. He's probably not the worst kill.
 
Gooner said:
This is an extremely questionable way to approach the game
Click to expand...

i can clarify, i mean for tejas alone

he's far better at the game as maf than as civ

especially as the game goes on, mafia has fewer places to hide, i understand that, you gotta start making good votes at some point
 
Gooner said:
What has Tejas done that you give him a whole civ read?
Click to expand...

to be fair to gooner I don’t know how I can be objectively civ at this point (other than I know my own alignment).

But I also think your logic on a few of your peeps gooner is quite wrong.
 
DeacdeTejas said:
to be fair to gooner I don’t know how I can be objectively civ at this point (other than I know my own alignment).

But I also think your logic on a few of your peeps gooner is quite wrong.
Click to expand...

I'm all ears, if you think I'm wrong tell me why and we can discuss it
 
Toogs said:
If Saul is the indy Kim is definitely helping him in some way, rough for Duff.
Click to expand...

Gotta say you have been popping in and out all game, avoiding any real heat. But you are definite im mafia. I'd still love to hear the reasoning for that statement.
 
DaDeacs said:
Still trying to figure out the deacon14 bribe thing. If we assume gouda bribed him night one, means he is not whatever mafia gouda is. But, he also wasn't told it was a banker and Juice was.

I am guessing the reasoning deacon14 was not told is either he is the other mafia or has no role or thing or whatever that can be bribed. He's probably not the worst kill.
Click to expand...

I do not understand the banker thing either, but have let it go. I assume it's because it affected Juice differently than me, but it still weirds me out.

My thoughts are mostly with Tejas and JMan currently, would vote either. I'd love to hear explanations from the people that have already voted for me about why I'm the choice, I'm assuming just process of elimination
 
Gooner said:
This is an extremely questionable way to approach the game
Click to expand...

Im not so sure. Mafia are the only players who ever start off with info. This makes both their reads easier and gives them unique advantages in collecting more info. Civs are always shooting in the dark. Period.
 
Duffterp said:
Gotta say you have been popping in and out all game, avoiding any real heat. But you are definite im mafia. I'd still love to hear the reasoning for that statement.
Click to expand...

I just said I was reaction testing you this morning do you see me voting for you?
 
as of 2163

d14 (4) jman, townie, gat, tejas
toogs (1) ph
knight (1) toogs
da (1) numbers
duff (1) knight
boston (1) duff
jman (1) D14
 
deacon14 said:
I do not understand the banker thing either, but have let it go. I assume it's because it affected Juice differently than me, but it still weirds me out.

My thoughts are mostly with Tejas and JMan currently, would vote either. I'd love to hear explanations from the people that have already voted for me about why I'm the choice, I'm assuming just process of elimination
Click to expand...

I do not think JMan is a good vote unless you are saying outright that you think he is faking either the RB (making him not Salamanca) or the weird vanilla claim he got warned for or both
 
Duffterp said:
Honestly like I mentioned I dont give Boston credit for teh bym vote.

That happened after the rommy AA, but before my reveal. He had to put his vote somewhere and I was pretty far out in the lead so there was no reason to think I would not go at that point without a claim. So why not put it on a teammate. He had no reason to believe at that point that:

A. I would claim
B. votes would move to Bym

IF that happened after my claim or he was 2nd or 3rd on Bym, I would be much more sold on him. Thats my read of it.

I also recall the whole backup cop talk, Boston brought it up and the next mention of a back up cop came from bym the next morning. Just small things like that when you already suspect someone pushed me to vote for him.
Click to expand...

These are some decent points
 
Vote count thru #2167

d14 (4) jman, townie, gat, tejas
duff (1) knight
knight (1) toogs
da (1) numbers
jman (1) d14
toogs (1) ph
boston (1) duff


YTV (5) gooner, da, jtp, tim, boston

PM if issues
 
Gooner said:
I do not think JMan is a good vote unless you are saying outright that you think he is faking either the RB (making him not Salamanca) or the weird vanilla claim he got warned for or both
Click to expand...

this is one of the things you are absolutely correct on. Jman is not a good vote
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top