For the morons:
Scout's rankings are still available through 2002. Since that time, here are our recruits, broken down by rating.
5-star
Chris Paul
AFA
Ty Walker
4-star
Justin Gray
Richard Joyce
Trent Strickland
Eric Willilams
Kevin Swinton
Ish Smith
Jamie Skeen
Anthony Gurley
Jeff Teague
James Johnson
Tony Woods
Ari Stewart
Travis McKie
Carson Desrosiers
JT Terrell
Melvin Tabb
3-star
Chris Ellis
Kyle Visser
Jeremy Ingram
Todd Hendley
Cam Stanley
David Weaver
Harvey Hale
LD Williams
Casey Crawford
Chas McFarland
Gary Clark
CJ Harris
Tony Chennault
Chase Fischer
2-star
Joe Dukes
Konner Tucker
Anthony Fields
Daniel Green
Among 5-star players, 2/3 made All-ACC (67%) with three total selections, 1/3 made first-team (33%), and 2/3 were draft picks (67%). One out of 3 was a bust (33%).
Among 4-star players, 6/16 made All-ACC (37.5%) with nine total selections, 1/16 made first-team (6%), and 2/16 were draft picks (12.5%). Jamie Skeen also made the All-CAA second team and Anthony Gurley made the All-A-10 third team in 2011, which would bump up to 50% with all-conference honors. To date, 2/16 are indisputable busts (12.5%), two (Stewart and Tabb) look likely (12.5%), and others are up in the air.
Among 3-star players, 2/14 made All-ACC (14.3%) with two total selections, 0/14 made first-team (0%), and 0/14 were draft picks (0%). Incidentally, both Harris and Visser, the two All-ACC honorees, were named to the third team following their senior year. To date, 4/14 are indisputable busts (28.6%), I'd give the same label to Ellis and Weaver (14.3%), and Chennault and Fischer appear likely (14.3%).
Among 2-star players, 0/4 made All-ACC (0%) with 0 total selections, 0/4 made first-team (0%) and 0/4 were or will be draft picks (0%). To this point, 3/4 are busts (75%).
ETA: Just looked back at the stats and would probably remove Ellis from the bust discussion (averaged 5.6 and 4.3 as a senior, played regularly except when hurt as a sophomore). Weaver, with a senior year line of 2.6 ppg and 2.1 rpg, qualifies, IMO.