deacdiggler
"Well known member"
- Joined
- Mar 28, 2011
- Messages
- 23,982
- Reaction score
- 12,107
Seems to me that a lot of calls get overturned without that elusive "indisputable video evidence.". I think officials should apply a simple test to these situations: "Are people going to be arguing about this replay tomorrow?". If yes, then it's not indisputable and the play should stand as called.
While I'm ranting, there is no circumstance in the world where a 200 pound man will fall on top of a piece of inflated rubber and the rubber won't move a little bit. Just because the ball touches the ground it doesn't mean that the ground helped the catch. Again - INDISPUTABLE is the test. The fact that we are disputing it proves that the ruling should have been upheld.
While I'm ranting, there is no circumstance in the world where a 200 pound man will fall on top of a piece of inflated rubber and the rubber won't move a little bit. Just because the ball touches the ground it doesn't mean that the ground helped the catch. Again - INDISPUTABLE is the test. The fact that we are disputing it proves that the ruling should have been upheld.