Apologies if this type of question has been addressed here at some point, I tried searching but 12 years of thread history is a lot to read...
We have some some large expenses coming due in the next month or so that outstrip our normal cashflow. Had an unexpected $20k plumbing issue recently that wasn't covered by insurance (awesome), have to pay the balance on a big trip the whole family is taking this summer, a couple other one-time things like that that are all coming together at once. Probably need $35k in February.
My question is, I'm trying to decide if it's better to take the money from a taxable brokerage account, or borrow the money (I have the option to take a line of credit through the brokerage firm at about 7.5% APR). The other variable is we're currently putting $2,500/month ($1,250 2x/month) into the brokerage account as part of overall savings plan.
With taking the money out of the brokerage account, the account value is reduced by $35k, plus there are likely some tax implications (will almost certainly have some cap gains that would be triggered). But I'm not paying any financing charges. We'd begin to rebuild the account balance almost immediately at $2,500/month, plus a larger lump sum contribution later this spring when my wife gets an annual bonus.
With taking the line of credit, the account balance isn't impacted, there is no taxable event, but I'm paying finance charges for the duration of the loan (probably will take 6-8 months to pay off), and there is also the opportunity cost of not being able to add to the investment account (because the brokerage will apply every deposit made to paying off the line of credit before allowing you to invest in the account) over that 6-8 month period, which is slightly concerning especially if the market stays flat/shitty - seems like a time that would be good to be buying in.
Any thoughts/advice on if one approach vs. the other is significantly better?