Who will be the better QB? Jameis Winston v. Tajh Boyd

[DeaconOEF/OIFvet]

To complement the FSU v. Clemson poll. Obviously, Winston is just going to get better in the following years. Who do you think will have the better collegiate career?

 

[Hogie]

 

[WRS]

Boyd has been very fortunate to have two truly elite WRs to throw to in Hopkins and Watkins. I'm not truly sold on him being a great QB.

 

[ChaosDeac]

Went with Boyd solely because I don't think Winston will be at FSU for the entire four years and thus might not get the stats compared to a four year Boyd.

 

[Deacfreak07]

Went with Boyd solely because I don't think Winston will be at FSU for the entire four years and thus might not get the stats compared to a four year Boyd.

The question is "who would you take" though.

 

[TBR]

Boyd has been very fortunate to have two truly elite WRs to throw to in Hopkins and Watkins. I'm not truly sold on him being a great QB.

I've never been blown away by Boyd myself.

 

[CumberlandDeac]

Winston has the potential to be the best quarterback in the NFL.

 

[Milhouse]

not named andrew luck

 

[CumberlandDeac]

not named andrew luck

Fair. Also, it's Tajh not Tahj.

 

[buckets]

i really like jameis

 

[DeaconOEF/OIFvet]

Fair. Also, it's Tajh not Tahj.

Fixed in the title. However, I cannot edit the name already listed in the poll.

 

[DiegoTiger]

I've never been blown away by Boyd myself.

Lulz.....takes a lot to impress you then.

 

[deacondamo]

For serious though, how in the hell did he get out of the state of Alabama?

 

[Ball State Deac]

not named andrew luck

Correct. Also, Winston may play baseball.

 

[TownieDeac]

Boyd is good. Jameis is outstanding.

 

[DiegoTiger]

Boyd is good. Jameis is outstanding.

How is Boyd only good in your opinion? What more would he need to accomplish to be great or outstanding?

I would also say Winston has the potential to be outstanding, but it's a little early to tell. I'd like to revisit the outstanding tag after Clemson, Miami, and Florida....

 

[Wakeforest22890]

Is Winston already better than Boyd?

Better in almost every statistic this year than Boyd, plus a substantially better QBR (whatever this metric actually measures)

 

[DiegoTiger]

Is Winston already better than Boyd?

Better in almost every statistic this year than Boyd, plus a substantially better QBR (whatever this metric actually measures)

Lol where's small sample size Deac when you need him?

Oh numbers....your hatred of Clemson is funny sometimes.

 

[WRS]

Diego do you not think that Boyd has benefited tremendously from throwing to Hopkins and Watson? That was my only point.

 

[stonevilleicetea]

Winston since you also get 1st round baseball talent.