gouda
Scooter Banks
- Joined
- May 14, 2014
- Messages
- 17,324
- Reaction score
- 562
also I didn't really read, did the specials do anything productive? Who were they?
Tim was angel, chic was watcher. Chic caught DA.
also I didn't really read, did the specials do anything productive? Who were they?
Tim was angel, chic was watcher. Chic caught DA.
at least 6. PS I knew knight was mafia because he didn't tell me the game started. How the fuck was I supposed to know the game started? It's tuesday morning with 17 pages of ryala sharting before I know there is a game?
You're right, the other 14 of us were secretly told when the game would start
I think it's far easier to rule people out as being captain's picks than to guess who would be picked. That said, I think Knight as mafia would do what he's doing. And if he is mafia, we've got a gang of data to go on.Knight said:Originally Posted by KnightOnly if he's the captain or the captain RNG'd. Rommy never makes end game. I would RNG, but I'd say at least half the players currently playing wouldn't RNG.
1. gouda - Doesn't get picked, dies too early. Only reason to pick him is to mitigate civ brain. Think would be a decent pick.
2. damo - Civ. Good job. Also think would be another good pick. Damo more than anything can just hide as mafia and last until end game.
3. bym - I'd pick him if I didn't RNG, but board is split on him. Unknown. Too risky imo
4. toogs - Civ. Plays like shit now. Major AA risk
5. SD3agles - Civ. Too risky to give away teammates. Not sure I buy the AA risk but a mafia captain would have be quite ballsy to pick SD3. High potential for being mafia's MVP as a civ
6. Tim - Civ. ^ Don't understand civ guarantee here. Another quiet guy that could last to end-game.
7. ryalabro - Coinflip. Good banter pick. Agreed.
8. Boston - Coinflip. Good stealth pick. Same logic here as Damo/TimDunk
9. #DudeLove - Civ. Dies to early. Did I miss someone's new nickname?
10. The Red Sox Suck - Civ. Too risky to give away teammates Disagree with Knight. Could see this being a decent wildcard play. Great at shitclouding the thread as mafia without being suspicious.
11. Chic - Coinflip. Good stealth pick. Girls don't get chosen. Move along.
12. Nonny - Mafia. Great stealth/braindrain. Civ.
13. doofus - Coinflip. Stealth would be outweighed by him giving away teammates. Sure.
14. romalom - Civ. Dies to early. Probably true.
15. Da - Coinflip. Think this is always one of the most popular picks. Far better mafia than civ.
So, until we get actual leads, the pool should be:
Ryala, Boston, Chic, Nonny, Doofus, Da.
But if not Knight...and if Knight is gonna stay this active I'm fine moving...I'd go Da.
I also went back through Knight's post and my reaction to it to get a better idea of what Knight was pushing. First off, props to him for actually building that list and taking a major risk. Because as mafia, it's very easy to just stay absent rather than putting yourself out there with a loki style list. But going with that risk, I think this is what also gave him away (or to me at least confirmed my initial suspicion). I disagreed too many times with his explanations, which similarly, making up faux-analysis is a very difficult thing for me when mafia.
I definitely disagreed with gouda not being a decent pick. And calling DA a coinflip as well when I think he is always a great captain's pick. But overall...props for Knight for putting this out there as it's no question a major risk when you're not completely honest with the analysis.
Tim protected me. Twice.
Someone in mafia chat said they were between me and you when they killed me and i protected you. I almost helped.
Someone in mafia chat said they were between me and you when they killed me and i protected you. I almost helped.
Someone in mafia chat said they were between me and you when they killed me and i protected you. I almost helped.