From the sample sizes you've been provided, would you say definitively that Danny Manning is a better head coach than Dino Gaudio?
Yes. When Danny had reasonable talent, he overachieved. Dino had excellent talent and grossly underachieved.
However, i wouldn't have minded Dino being Danny's defensive coach might have been the best combination.
Do not read this as saying Danny didn't underachieve this year. He did.