• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

Infinite Jest Mafia - Gouda hands the CIVs a win

Eagles_Legendz said:
That was a very good but frustrating game. Thank you for running GAt.
Click to expand...

Apologies but your tone felt off. I was standing strong on you being the final piece until the bitter end. Ironically, you almost turned me the day of the first Tim lynch onto SD3 but then you just ran pirsig when SD3 wasn't working for you, I read that as you desperate for a mislynch. I didn't read anything that would have me vote for pirsig.

I did, however, protect you 2x at night.
 
Eagles_Legendz said:
I didn’t feel great about anyone being mafia. I think every civ I leaned was right and my voting pools were good but I never was able to feel confident about any mafia which is funny because my substantive votes were juice d1 sd3 d2 before ph’s post da d3 etc.

But I was spending all of my energy trying to protect tim while being told I was either mafia or dumb or weird or off. It gets tough to post the same thing over and over again when you’re swimming up stream to convince people you aren’t mafia, while trying to convince other people someone else isn’t mafia (and you don’t know for sure yourself).
Click to expand...

If I was civ, I would have voted out tim too - that role and play was -ev for the team, especially to get pretty average powers. Reporter? Voyeur? Even if true, its not worth the vote switch and killing townie, who he knew was a civ.
 
Eagles_Legendz said:
I didn’t feel great about anyone being mafia. I think every civ I leaned was right and my voting pools were good but I never was able to feel confident about any mafia which is funny because my substantive votes were juice d1 sd3 d2 before ph’s post da d3 etc.

But I was spending all of my energy trying to protect tim while being told I was either mafia or dumb or weird or off. It gets tough to post the same thing over and over again when you’re swimming up stream to convince people you aren’t mafia, while trying to convince other people someone else isn’t mafia (and you don’t know for sure yourself).
Click to expand...

Everyone in dead chat minus dv7 was with you on not killing tim
 
Gooner said:
Nonny nailing me with the RB was arguably the civ play of the game because everything that came after it pretty much originated with N4.
Click to expand...

Ironic that it actually left you alive a day longer at first (I went after persig instead of you bc of the 2/3 thing) but then eventually led to your demise with numbers’ strong pull.
 
I think if gouda doesn't ice Da N3 and kills random civ X, maf wins. That one was the real death blow for us because then it was just SD3 and me trying to justify survival.
 
mako1331 said:
How did I dumb tell
Click to expand...

You voted for me after I died. Generally speaking, when people do that it is like 99.8% of the time a civ and a clearing thing - because mafia would know a) I was their dead teammate b) be paying close attention to know not to vote for dead people.

Its rarely malicious, but hurts mafia.
 
DaDeacs said:
You voted for me after I died. Generally speaking, when people do that it is like 99.8% of the time a civ and a clearing thing - because mafia would know a) I was their dead teammate b) be paying close attention to know not to vote for dead people.

Its rarely malicious, but hurts mafia.
Click to expand...

once a mafia person does it intentionally, all hell will break loose
 
WhisperingEye said:
Apologies but your tone felt off. I was standing strong on you being the final piece until the bitter end. Ironically, you almost turned me the day of the first Tim lynch onto SD3 but then you just ran pirsig when SD3 wasn't working for you, I read that as you desperate for a mislynch. I didn't read anything that would have me vote for pirsig.

I did, however, protect you 2x at night.
Click to expand...

I only moved to Pirsig when no one else came to sd3. I tried to kill sd3 that round. And my Pirsig vote was because he was a ?? to me when Tim was a civ so there was at least a chance he was bad. You played well. You dug out of being a mafia lean to a civ lean for me and then back to ?? at the very end when I had so many others as solid civs.
 
Had I known that Juice was going to get smoked by JMan on N2 anyway, I probably would have helped lynch him D1 for credit. Felt bad that it was between maf GF and D14 in his first real game for the D1 lynch.
 
Eagles_Legendz said:
I didn’t feel great about anyone being mafia. I think every civ I leaned was right and my voting pools were good but I never was able to feel confident about any mafia which is funny because my substantive votes were juice d1 sd3 d2 before ph’s post da d3 etc.

But I was spending all of my energy trying to protect tim while being told I was either mafia or dumb or weird or off. It gets tough to post the same thing over and over again when you’re swimming up stream to convince people you aren’t mafia, while trying to convince other people someone else isn’t mafia (and you don’t know for sure yourself).
Click to expand...

Definitely was a game of clearing civs vs catching mafia. Partly bc of the night mafia hits but also just the way voting worked.

Gooner and Knight really the only two who got got from their voting history.
 
Eagles_Legendz said:
I only moved to Pirsig when no one else came to sd3. I tried to kill sd3 that round. And my Pirsig vote was because he was a ?? to me when Tim was a civ so there was at least a chance he was bad. You played well. You dug out of being a mafia lean to a civ lean for me and then back to ?? at the very end when I had so many others as solid civs.
Click to expand...

I know you'll never tell me but I have to know what tone thing you have on me because I need to fix it posthaste
 
Gooner said:
Had I known that Juice was going to get smoked by JMan on N2 anyway, I probably would have helped lynch him D1 for credit. Felt bad that it was between maf GF and D14 in his first real game for the D1 lynch.
Click to expand...

lol it's cool bro, I probably earned that lynch by shitposting the way I did
 
DaDeacs said:
You voted for me after I died. Generally speaking, when people do that it is like 99.8% of the time a civ and a clearing thing - because mafia would know a) I was their dead teammate b) be paying close attention to know not to vote for dead people.

Its rarely malicious, but hurts mafia.
Click to expand...

Yeah. I was trying to show that I was right about being on you the whole time and switched my stars. I knew you were dead as I explained directly after but yeah, still apologies there. I don’t think it was a straight dumb tell but still sorry guys.
 
Gooner said:
Had I known that Juice was going to get smoked by JMan on N2 anyway, I probably would have helped lynch him D1 for credit. Felt bad that it was between maf GF and D14 in his first real game for the D1 lynch.
Click to expand...

FTR it was either you (out of spite) or Juice. I wasn’t planning on using my hit at all until PH did his thing.
 
AnonymousDeac said:
Definitely was a game of clearing civs vs catching mafia. Partly bc of the night mafia hits but also just the way voting worked.

Gooner and Knight really the only two who got got from their voting history.
Click to expand...

Yeaaahhhhhh, my voting history was bad lol. However, I am not historically known for being good at that so :shrug:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top