• Welcome to OGBoards 10.0, keep in mind that we will be making LOTS of changes to smooth out the experience here and make it as close as possible functionally to the old software, but feel free to drop suggestions or requests in the Tech Support subforum!

DUNE Mafia -Game over, CIVS WIN

deacondamo said:
Nice.
Click to expand...

One bone to pick with you. I think your logic was awful regarding my post about redwing and the huge fonts. I would have made the exact same post if I were a civ. Why in the world did you think that was a mafia post?
 
I'll work on filling in the rest of the roles on page one. Thanks for bearing with us here. This was the first time for both SLT and myself, so there were some rough edges. Also it didn't help that there were five mafia players killed before a single civ. I appreciate all comments, criticism, praise and/or hate mail you would like to share.
 
WFU03 said:
One bone to pick with you. I think your logic was awful regarding my post about redwing and the huge fonts. I would have made the exact same post if I were a civ. Why in the world did you think that was a mafia post?
Click to expand...

This. I would have made that post if I was a civ, because it was fairly obvious that toppings wasn't converted and Redwing was telling you that. I didn't make it because you guys conveniently disregarded the fact that there was a distinction between hunting and searching.
 
redwing42 said:
I'll work on filling in the rest of the roles on page one. Thanks for bearing with us here. This was the first time for both SLT and myself, so there were some rough edges. Also it didn't help that there were five mafia players killed before a single civ. I appreciate all comments, criticism, praise and/or hate mail you would like to share.
Click to expand...

I had no idea this was a co-modded game. :tard:
 
We_Win.jpg
 
You are Piter de Vries, twisted Mentat and advisor to Baron Harkonnen. You are brilliant, devious, and an invaluable asset to House Harkonnen. You are searching for Wanna Marcus, wife to the House Atreides doctor, Wellington Yueh. If you are able to find her, she is killed and Dr. Yueh is converted to your mafia team. This will be announced in the game thread.

My role if anyone's interested. Thufir Hawat and Leto II were the two safe claims we were given.
 
I honestly think the roles were fair. When Smiley no-shows and 4 other mafia die immediately it is going to seem civ-slanted after the fact.
 
lol at kanoki and knight. I vig hit you to keep you from getting a win.
 
Sweet!LaserTag! said:
I honestly think the roles were fair. When Smiley no-shows and 4 other mafia die immediately it is going to seem civ-slanted after the fact.
Click to expand...

Smiley no showing was a big two person sway. Instead of him likely surviving past day 4 and me thus dying, he was admin killed and I survived.
 
Sweet!LaserTag! said:
I honestly think the roles were fair. When Smiley no-shows and 4 other mafia die immediately it is going to seem civ-slanted after the fact.
Click to expand...

We went after Corrino too much at the beginning. 7erps really shouldn't have gone out on a limb just to kill Raise.
 
I'm confused. The other mafia had one fewer member?

Don't have time to get into this now on my phone, but Kanhoji, your anger at QT was misplaced. She outed gsterp by herself and was pretty spot on. In a game with these roles where the civs have numbers towards the end, the more info out the better.

Other than that you played a great game for your second game ever.

As I said in the signup thread, posrep heading out for all survivors when I get back.
 
Oh and thanks to the mods. Game was fun. Good participation all around. Looking forward to a standardish game next.
 
Agreed. Thanks redwing and SLT. Very well run, particularly for first timers.
 
Eagles_Legendz said:
Oh and thanks to the mods. Game was fun. Good participation all around. Looking forward to a standardish game next.
Click to expand...

+1

Mods did a good job. Some small growing pains with the new mods but nothing that affected the game. Both took hard stances on the issues and were not swayed by the players. I enjoyed it.
 
Sweet!LaserTag! said:
I honestly think the roles were fair. When Smiley no-shows and 4 other mafia die immediately it is going to seem civ-slanted after the fact.
Click to expand...

I would like to think that the civs stellar play led to the civ win. Multifactorial.

I will admit I was excited to be a civ after being mafia three games in a row. I might have been...overzealous.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top