Better Call Saul, The Mafia Game. Indies Win! Gooner, GAT and Duff

[JuiceCrewAllStar]

that's really strange because the OP implies there will be independents in this game.

those are not inconsistent

 

[redwing42]

this guys is mafia and should be ignored.

Stop being obstinate for a minute and think about the potential uses of a mason paring with a cop. If you have that advantage, why reveal it all in thread for mafia to wipe out?

 

[Wakeforest22890]

I’m fine with going, but note the late jumps when it gets close to majo

Also, look into the numbers/juice interactions. They’re gonna look bad.

Lol wut

 

[Wakeforest22890]

***mako***

Also safe claims are not a crutch theyre needed unless the rules don’t allow you to give the name of your role.

 

[DeacdeTejas]

The last ten mins make me want to flip my rw and jtp reads

 

[Gooner]

This is the civviest thing rw has said all game

And its also true. Juices claim works itself out. He either eventually misses or he is correct and we shouldnt force anything out of him

I mean we're not super far removed from Knight being "cop" and controlling multiple consecutive rounds as mafia because he had more information. I'm far more concerned with Juice's initial claim/reluctance and the delay in giving us an investigation (which Juice finally claimed was numbers) than whether or not mako is bad.

But in almost any realistic scenario where Juice isn't white flagging as a fake claim, mako has to be bad. If Juice really is faking, then mako has to be bad to keep the facade up. The alternative is Juice really is Hank and therefore mako is mafia.

***switch to mako***

I want to make it clear that this whole Juice thing is a giant clusterfuck and also redwing is still definitely mafia.

 

[PhDeac]

Stop being obstinate for a minute and think about the potential uses of a mason paring with a cop. If you have that advantage, why reveal it all in thread for mafia to wipe out?

Fair points, but several of us are skeptical that Juice is the Cop. There's plenty of reason he would be and plenty that he isn't. It's not that urgent at this point and time will reveal what's going on.

 

[ryalaman]

Everyone shut the fuck up about Gomez. He's probably a backup cop or juice is actually gomez. Not worth fishing for a claim

 

[Eagles_Legendz]

***mako***

My actual eta to the thread is like 9pm.

 

[Gooner]

so does parlay

 

[Wakeforest22890]

I mean we're not super far removed from Knight being "cop" and controlling multiple consecutive rounds as mafia because he had more information. I'm far more concerned with Juice's initial claim/reluctance and the delay in giving us an investigation (which Juice finally claimed was numbers) than whether or not mako is bad.

But in almost any realistic scenario where Juice isn't white flagging as a fake claim, mako has to be bad. If Juice really is faking, then mako has to be bad to keep the facade up. The alternative is Juice really is Hank and therefore mako is mafia.

***switch to mako***

I want to make it clear that this whole Juice thing is a giant clusterfuck and also redwing is still definitely mafia.

Yes mako is definitely bad. If juice is mafia he’s bussing a teammate and if he’s civ he’s got mafia

 

[romanovKU]

Rommy knows better than this. Flagging for later.

go ahead and flag. gonna laugh when mako flips civ

 

[JuiceCrewAllStar]

gooner, explain why it is inconsistent to be the cop and to withhold outing citizens day 2?

 

[Wakeforest22890]

...and yet JMan lives.

 

[Gooner]

Yes mako is definitely bad. If juice is mafia he’s bussing a teammate and if he’s civ he’s got mafia

Thank you for repeating what I said I'm assuming for emphasis and not because you have to type stuff out to prove you have basic reading comprehension skills

 

[jtpterp]

all the late pile on's now make me think juiceis telling the truth.


which are teammates look for a sliver of credit? YOU GET NONE.

 

[romanovKU]

those are not inconsistent

you are getting "mafia" back yet there could be independents in the game. what would they return as? it doesn't make sense. your report should be town/anti-town

 

[jtpterp]

The last ten mins make me want to flip my rw and jtp reads

this is a useless post.

just flip them in your next useless list post w/ a dumbtell.

 

[DeacdeTejas]

I mean we're not super far removed from Knight being "cop" and controlling multiple consecutive rounds as mafia because he had more information. I'm far more concerned with Juice's initial claim/reluctance and the delay in giving us an investigation (which Juice finally claimed was numbers) than whether or not mako is bad.

But in almost any realistic scenario where Juice isn't white flagging as a fake claim, mako has to be bad. If Juice really is faking, then mako has to be bad to keep the facade up. The alternative is Juice really is Hank and therefore mako is mafia.

***switch to mako***

I want to make it clear that this whole Juice thing is a giant clusterfuck and also redwing is still definitely mafia.

Right. But that knight fake claim also netted 3 maf and was +EV for civs.

I have juice on my mafia list still. And have stated i think rw is bad (though I like his last two posts a lot).

But it doesnt change the fact the play is mako and the play is to ride juice as cop until it is proven he isnt. Just like it was with knight

 

[Gooner]

gooner, explain why it is inconsistent to be the cop and to withhold outing citizens day 2?

It's not inconsistent, just dumb. Regardless of outing who or what, waiting hours to reveal an investigation is dumb.