Cake or pie?

[BarcaDeac]

can also do fewer layers, but that's what we had growing up...popular in New Orleans and the Deep South

 

[lokisapocalypse]

What cake is there that trumps pecan pie?

Cookie cake.

 

[Demonwolverine]

Cookie cake.

What's next? Are we going to start calling brownies cake?

Even so, I'm still a pie guy.

 

[bym051d]

caramel, red velvet, carrot, tres leches

German chocolate, black forest.

 

[HailToTheDeacons]

No it doesn't. By that logic we must include cow pies too.

But also cream pies.

 

[CantStandYa]

Pie, because pies can be savory and not just sweet fatty mcfattits desserts. I don't really like sweets but I will crush a good meat pie. I'll take a bomb shepards pie or pot pie all day.

So then we're including crab cakes, etc?

 

[HailToTheDeacons]

Cookie cake.

 

[tigerswood]

So then we're including crab cakes, etc?

If so, then game, set, match. Not to mention salmon cakes, potato cakes, corn cakes, and PANCAKES.

 

[Shooshmoo]

Also, cake by the ocean. That's right -- I'm talking sexual intercourse. Changing my vote.

 

[lbE08]

Pie.

That said, if we're going crappy store-bought whatever, I would rather have crappy sheet cake than crappy store-bought cherry pie with weirdly gelatinous filling.

 

[wakelaw13]

If so, then game, set, match. Not to mention salmon cakes, potato cakes, corn cakes, and PANCAKES.

Damn. I'm on this team.

 

[ImTheCaptain]

has anyone made a

joke, yet?

 

[ImTheCaptain]

Pie.

That said, if we're going crappy store-bought whatever, I would rather have crappy sheet cake than crappy store-bought cherry pie with weirdly gelatinous filling.

that's because cherry pie sucks

 

[JuiceCrewAllStar]

Graham cracker crust is sex

 

[ImTheCaptain]

...for people who don't know how to make a real crust

 

[TownieDeac]

one need look no further than this thread to see itc has trash opinions

 

[BarcaDeac]

...for people who don't know how to make a real crust

my wife knows how to make both and makes great pie crust, but graham crust is just better.

 

[Biff Tannen]

Why judge the cake or pie debate based on the worst possible cake or pie ? Bad cake and pie can be easily avoided.

 

[HailToTheDeacons]

Pie.

That said, if we're going crappy store-bought whatever, I would rather have crappy sheet cake than crappy store-bought cherry pie with weirdly gelatinous filling.

No love for these calorie-bombs?

 

[lbE08]

No love for these calorie-bombs?

Those are on a different level. Not part of the sheet cake vs. bad pie discussion.