AttilatheHoo
Well-known member
would prolly be difficult to tunnel due to frozen ground.
would prolly be difficult to tunnel due to frozen ground.
With 100,000 men you'd think you could just build your own tunnel.
Anyway, it's a story.
Btw,
if you aren't reading "Ask the Maester" on Grantland, you should be, esp if you're not a book reader.
mebbe with dragons but interesting question.But GIANTS. If it can't be done with 100,000 men and giants, how'd it get done in the first place!?
But GIANTS. If it can't be done with 100,000 men and giants, how'd it get done in the first place!?
would prolly be difficult to tunnel due to frozen ground.
Well assuming a lot of things and simplifying the process a lot, heat of fusion of ice being like 350kJ/kg, then the combustible properties of wood being something like 15,000 kJ/kg you could melt 42kg of ice for every kg of wood. Now solid ice comes in at 28kg per cubic foot, so to walk through need about 6 feet high and 2 feet wide, so for ever foot through the wall need to melt 336kg of ice. Assume the wall is 300 feet thick? So need to melt 100,800kg of ice, or 2400kg of wood which isn't a ton, well it is around 3 tons but they just lit way more of that on fire. Then again the wall is made of magic and shit, and fire isn't going to be direct heat to ice transfer but you really should be able to just melt the damn thing.
They built the wall around the tunnel.But GIANTS. If it can't be done with 100,000 men and giants, how'd it get done in the first place!?
Nope real numbers, but should of just googled Game of Thrones Melt the Wall with Fire, because more precise math has been done.
Did anybody else instantly think this when Sam was talking to Gillie in that storage room at Castle Black?
Did anybody else instantly think this when Sam was talking to Gillie in that storage room at Castle Black?