For fun, and to satisfy my curiousity, I looked through a few years of results on this thing. The fact of the matter is that it is amazing that we have been able to finish as high as we have many of these years. Essentially every sport we play has to be competitive on a national basis and earn points in order for us to be in the top 40 or so...
In '00-'01 we placed 33rd. We earned points in m&w cc, field hockey (final 4), w soccer, m basketball, w track and field (we used to regularly earn points here - I assume that was from our distance runners?), baseball, w golf (high finish), w tennis, m tennis. That is 10/16 possible sports, with a couple of high finishes.
In '01-'02 we placed 42nd. We earned points in m cc, field hockey (final 4), w soccer, m soccer, m basketball, w track and field, baseball, w golf (high finish), m golf, w tennis, m tennis. That is 11/16 possible sports, with a couple of high finishes.
In '02-'03 we placed 32nd. We earned points in w cc, field hockey (natty), w soccer, m soccer (high finish), m basketball, w track and field, w golf, m golf (4th?), m tennis. That is 9/16 possible sports, with a nat title, a 4th place and another high finish.
Those are actually pretty amazing years for us.
In '09-'10 we finished 53rd and still had 7/16 teams producing points - but, no points from cc or t&f or w tennis...
In '10-'11 we finished 74th and only had 6/16 teams producing - no cc, no baseball, no basketball, no m tennis, no m soccer.