Pilchard
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 3, 2011
- Messages
- 17,181
- Reaction score
- 6,453
Jeff Bagwell getting in ahead of Vlad, Bonds and Clemens makes a mockery of the HoF. Jeff Bagwell was a nice player on a good team for a decade, but neither he nor his team was ever great.
Also, one of the arguments against Bonds despite the lack of a positive PED test is the change in body type. Bagwell went from a skinny corner infielder to a hulk right in the middle of the steroid era. Yes, there was no BALCO-like investigation with the feds using subpoena power and the threat of putting others in jail to conclusively determine PED use for Bags, but do you know why? Because he was Jeff F-ing Bagwell and no one cared that he was using PEDs. The force of the federal government got behind trying to establish Barry Bonds was using because he was the greatest in the game for decades; Barry Bonds mattered; Jeff Bagwell was a footnote. Unless there is going to be an extensive Balco-like investigation of every HoF candidate that played the game between 1990 and the mid 2000s; you can't elect guys like Jeff Bagwell (or Pudge Rodriguez who has a direct link to PEDs as well) and keep out far superior players simply because the time was taken to investigate them, but not less accomplished players that did the same thing.
Also, one of the arguments against Bonds despite the lack of a positive PED test is the change in body type. Bagwell went from a skinny corner infielder to a hulk right in the middle of the steroid era. Yes, there was no BALCO-like investigation with the feds using subpoena power and the threat of putting others in jail to conclusively determine PED use for Bags, but do you know why? Because he was Jeff F-ing Bagwell and no one cared that he was using PEDs. The force of the federal government got behind trying to establish Barry Bonds was using because he was the greatest in the game for decades; Barry Bonds mattered; Jeff Bagwell was a footnote. Unless there is going to be an extensive Balco-like investigation of every HoF candidate that played the game between 1990 and the mid 2000s; you can't elect guys like Jeff Bagwell (or Pudge Rodriguez who has a direct link to PEDs as well) and keep out far superior players simply because the time was taken to investigate them, but not less accomplished players that did the same thing.
Last edited: