but do you get things like peanut butter and toilet paper from amazon?
I have never looked for things like that on Amazon, but I buy most everything else there, or at least give them first dibs. It is my go to place for:
1. Video game pre-orders - They ship so you have the game on launch day if you have Prime and you almost always get some Amazon specific promotion for pre ordering through them
2. Eye drops for our rescue dog - Yep, she produces no tears so we have to lube up her peepers
3. Shampoo and Conditioner
4. Camera and Laptop accessories - just bout a microSD card for my phone and a laptop battery through them.
5. Razor blades - Make sure you don't order them all near Halloween though. Space it out through the year to avoid the FBI list.
6. Accessories for my Jeep - Although their selection here is lacking, so I usually end up elsewhere.
7. Almost all birthday and Christmas gifts.
The fact that prime gives me free two day shipping puts me in the same camp as Deadbolt. I will almost always use Amazon first, if possible, because I know my stuff will be at my door in two days.