Captain's Choice Mafia Pickability Power Rankings
1) rommy - Good selection for mafia proficiency but also for chat proficiency
2) Eagles - #1 pick if just on mafia proficiency
3) Townie - Solid chatter, burgeoning mafia talent, stock as high as any new player's can be
4) tic - Great chatter, boom or bust as a mafia player, but his highest highs are far higher than his lowest lows
5) bym - Will fly under the radar, underestimated as a mafia player, solid chatter
6) GAT - Great chatter, a "doesn't take anything off the table" mafia player
7) gouda - Solid chatter, might be able to draw out 75% effort because you picked him which will make him feel special
8) SD3 - Expert at "wait how is he alive on D6" playstyle, good chat skills
9) parlay - Haven't been in a maf chat with him recently but no doubt brings an A game, solid if slightly "is there a screw loose" mafia play
10) D14 - Could easily usurp Townie as "best new player" if Townie starts slacking with the ego boost, haven't chatted with him yet but seems like he'd be enjoyable
11) JMan - Underrated mafia player, won't hurt the team, no idea on chat skills
12) Nonny - Solid maf player but haven't seen enough play from him due to late signups recently, I'm sure he's lovely in chat
13) Mako - top tier chat skills, may help your team by dumbtelling himself clear despite being the person who submitted the night hit
14) WFU03 - Good chatter but every post he ever posts seems like mafia which is bad when he's actually mafia
15) dv7 - May get AA'd so though he has solid chat skills, that's too far a risk to take