RedSoxFaithful
a vicar in a tutu
- Joined
- Oct 7, 2011
- Messages
- 27,241
- Reaction score
- 4,644
so I noticed that Lady Bird dropped below 100% on RT, and I was flipping through the review blurbs from the negative reviewer, and I saw this, from his Wonder Woman review, which he gave an F:
Now, look. I'm fine with an F review, and I'm fine with this dude being a pretentious contrarian. But what the fuck is that metaphor? "As boring and flavorless as a three-day-old grilled cheese sandwich that's been left out in the sun"?
If I find a grilled cheese that has been sitting outside for a few days, I'm not going to be bored. I'm going to have questions. Like: why was this grilled cheese sandwich left here? Did someone forget about it? What could make somebody abandon an entire grilled cheese? Is the person okay? Have they done this sort of thing before? What sort of cheese did they use? And flavorless? I've never eaten three day old trash food, but I'm going to assume that this imaginary sandwich is full of flavors. Even if the three days haven't aged its tastes, it's still, you know, a grilled cheese. Those taste like something! And then those three days happened, and, look, you can say the three day old sandwich is disgusting or it smells bad or it's covered in maggots, but it's going to taste like something. Probably lots of things!
Anyway. Cole Smithey should feel bad about this bad metaphor, and also about his stupid ass name.
As boring and flavorless as a three-day-old grilled cheese sandwich that's been left out in the sun, "Wonder Woman" is yet another reminder that the superhero genre is a lost cause.
Now, look. I'm fine with an F review, and I'm fine with this dude being a pretentious contrarian. But what the fuck is that metaphor? "As boring and flavorless as a three-day-old grilled cheese sandwich that's been left out in the sun"?
If I find a grilled cheese that has been sitting outside for a few days, I'm not going to be bored. I'm going to have questions. Like: why was this grilled cheese sandwich left here? Did someone forget about it? What could make somebody abandon an entire grilled cheese? Is the person okay? Have they done this sort of thing before? What sort of cheese did they use? And flavorless? I've never eaten three day old trash food, but I'm going to assume that this imaginary sandwich is full of flavors. Even if the three days haven't aged its tastes, it's still, you know, a grilled cheese. Those taste like something! And then those three days happened, and, look, you can say the three day old sandwich is disgusting or it smells bad or it's covered in maggots, but it's going to taste like something. Probably lots of things!
Anyway. Cole Smithey should feel bad about this bad metaphor, and also about his stupid ass name.