Odom recruited well at the beginning and the end but horribly in the middle. A lot of that I blame on Ricky Stokes. After Stokes left, and Haith came in, that's when we landed that ROK class and JoHo.
I think Odom's recruiting was actually pretty consistent throughout.
Here's a snapshot of the players he brought in (with help from Charlie Board) and my recollections of rankings. Both are open to corrections.
Bold = All ACC, Italics = committed but did not qualify.
91 Additions -
Rogers (5-star),
Childress (top 60),
Trelonnie (top 100), Blucas, Doggett, StanKing
92 Additions - Scooter, Derrick Hicks (JuCo entered as JR), David Rasmussen (JuCo entered as JR), Cordell Llewellyn
93 Additions - Steve Rich (top 40), Charlie Harrison (GTown transfer entered as JR, top 60),Castle, Canty, Fitzgibbons,
94 Additions -
Duncan, Schoone (redshirt),
Mahktar (top 40)
95 Additions -
Rutland, Peral (entered as SO) Braswell, Goolsby, AJ, Allen (JuCo entered as JR, injured in game 4/redshirted)
96 Additions - Stringfellow (top 100), Armond Wilson, Ammo, Rodney West (redshirt?)
97 Additions - Woods (5-star),
Coleman (top 75), Blom
98 Additions -
Rok (top 35), Viduaretta (top 100), Griffin (top 100), Arinze, Pumpfaker, McMillian
Blom?
99 Additions -
Darius (top 40), Dawson (top 75), Scott (top 100), Hicks (top 100), Murray
00 Additions -
JHo
01 Additions - AW, Schoetz
02 Additions - Levy (top 50)
Vytas*(top 75), Taron
Every year Odom brought in ranked recruits or in the case of 92, 95, & 00, recruits that significantly exceeded their rankings. (The Awww Shitz class being the exception). Granted the 96 class was extremely weak as String underachieved & no one else overachieved but overall not any glaring gaps in bringing in talent
I think our talent depletion mid Odom was more due to misfortune than poor recruiting.
1. The loss of Steve Rich one semester into his frosh season hurt not because he was a great player but because he had the skill set we lacked, a physical center. Rich would have benefited Duncan for 3 years. He had a solid career @ Miami.
2. Mahktar has already been mentioned except that I will add that part of the punishment for his violation included not recruiting foreign players which likely hurt the 95/96 classes
3. Woods being a headcase also already mentioned but he certainly had the talent to keep our NCAA streak alive
4. Coleman, a solid player for UGA but he again possessed a skill set we lacked on Duncan's last team, a slashing wing. To make matters worse he chose JuCo over Prep so we could not even bring him in for the following class.
5. Blom. If I'm not mistaken we lost him in two classes (I found articles listing him as a newcomer in both 97 & 98). I also recall that when he wasn't admitted, he played pro on a team in Sweden with Trelonnie & Scooter and was team mvp and/or leading scorer. That certainly points to him being ACC caliber & capable of contributing immediately.
6. Probably the biggest misfortune for Odom was having two of his best teams (93 & 96) in the same bracket as two of Pitino's best UK teams, esp 96.