I thought it was the opposite. They would mostly be closed, but would occasionally be open.
Regarding red-shirting, I think the physical/size component is more significant than the level of skill a true freshman possesses. It is rare that a kid right out of high school is physically developed to the extent that he can compete against players who are just one or two steps away from the NFL. The strength programs in college along with the natural growth and development of 18-22 yr. olds would dictate that most recruits should red-shirt. Of course there are exceptions but they truly are exceptions.
Right. Most, if not all of this 2014 class could play right away from a skill standpoint, but the redshirt allows some guys to develop physically without wasting a year of eligibility.
That's not really true. Most players need some time to develop the skills necessary to compete in college. Receivers need time to understand the playbook and perfect routes that usually aren't run in high school. DBs need time to perfect coverage techniques other than cover-2, cover-3, and man. DLs have to work on improving hand placement and technique. The list goes on.
so where did the RB RIcks end up?