Overall Town Grade: C-
5) SD3 Civ - Vanilla: Grade: C The Damo dumbtell and the nilla on (claimed) nilla violence at the end of D3 were ... not great Bob.
6) Townie Civ - Vanilla: Grade: A- Had Maf nailed dead to rights over the last 2-3 days but couldn't get the town to follow. Kind of a shame, really.
16) Gooner Civ - Vanilla: Grade: C+ In this this game just being active and not fucking up give you a better than average grade. That quick vote on D8 though. Woof.
18) QT Civ - Vanilla: Grade: B Stayed solid and factual with reads, just wanted more of them. especially early. Likely hard with not playing as much lately
21) Tim Civ - Vanilla: Grade: I Poor bastard died N1 and still had more posts than Blue
22) Damo Civ - Vanilla: Grade: B Died early but did enough as a nilla civ to draw the Maf hit
3) Gouda Civ - Vanilla (w/ test): Grade: C To be honest, i don't remember much
25) Beads Civ CDC: Grade: XF And then had the balls to PM me that it was a bullshit AA "because martial law means anything goes" LOLWUT?
7) Ph Civ Cop: Grade: B- The AA was bad but that's partly on me. His investigations were good and he hit 2/5 mafia. Couldn't really lead with low post #s
15) WFU03 Civ Epidemiologist: Grade C- That bad/late claim started the worst 75 minutes of mafia i've ever seen (Bern claim, Ph AA). Gotta be earlier/clearer
4) Mako Civ ER Doc: Grade B+ Played his role well for how new his is. Stayed under the radar & helped keep townies alive. Tough to fake nilla after soft claim.
26) Duff Civ GF Hunter: Grade: C Would've been higher for his late game rational play but for the miss on releasing his investigation results on Blue
24) Eagles Civ Mayor: Grade: APlayed his role well, declared curfew at right time allowing Ryala to get a bunch of info on N3. Good reads as always.
12) Ryala Civ Nat'l Guard: Grade: B Had the info to push Da earlier. As confirmed Civ needed to play a bigger role leading the endgame.
14) Jman Civ Nat'l Guard: Grade: I Never really got to use his ability or engage in the game.
13) TurtleInChains Civ Tracker: Grade: B Hit N1 on tracking results.
10) Numbers Civ Watcher: Grade: B-Hit on watches: Ph N1 with 2 visitors,SD3 N3 with 2 visitors, Ph again when Da visited. Needed to do more with info
20) JTP COVID-19: Grade: XF AA'ed
17) Knight Trump: Grade A+ with honorary PhD in jimmie rustling. Played part to perfection. Exactly what Toogs and I wanted. Born for this role.
Overall Mafia Grade: C- Probably should give a higher grade since they won but i can't abide by maf playing the quiet strategy. Also fuck you for stealing the gift of TIC overnight with KnightTrump from us all.
9) BeachBum Maf ER Doc: Grade: B+ Played the role well in the same vein as Mako. Under the radar. Keeping teammates alive.
23) DeaconBlue Maf GF Grade: D Missing for huge stretches. Constant AA risk, low post count. Life gets in the way but i have to grade on the body of work
1) redwing Maf Goon Grade: C Similar to Blue but posted more. After death wasn't around to help maf strategize
8) Bern Maf Goon Grade: F Terrible claim made worse by not saying anything about it in maf chad. Full Leeeeeeeeeeroy Jenkins. Tough to watch, honestly.
19) dv7 Maf Goon Grade: A- Played well in the endgame but (maybe unfairly) felt like he was hiding in the early game
27) Whispering Parleyes Maf Goon: Grade: B Helpful in the endgame with strategy after his death.
2) Romulus Maf RB Pre-Death Grade: D+, Posthumous Grade: A+ Was 100% thrown by Eagles early attention. Could not figure out what to post or how to post it. Literally like looking in a mirror for me. And i didn't like it. More or less useless while alive. After death when the pressure of Eagles was off, rallied strongly and led the charge on everything that happened on the Maf side.
Indy:
11) Da Civ - Vanilla: Grade: A Took a role switch to the most complex role in the game in the middle of Day 1 and nearly won as an Indy. Only miss was not using the Superspreader earlier #Respeck
Mod:
Toogs: Grade: A+ Huuuugely helpful and ended up running more than half the game. By the end, knew the setup better than i did.
Gat: Grade: C- No major mistakes but long nights sucked for game momentum. Also the Ph AA was not ideal. And calling the game before it was over was awful.