I think most people would be at home in the Episcopal Church. I'd suggest just going and trying it (Episcopal or progressive Baptist) out. You're not likely going to get that urge by not doing anything, but it seems like you've at least got a small one. Also, our culture tends to view Church from the point of view of a consumer- where we get something out of Church. But it really is just about worship. Don't worry about joining a community or anything like that (yet)- just go, pray, sing, worship. Give the Spirit more of a chance to do it's thing. If nothing else, find a place that has really good preaching and go for that. It's a process, you don't have to get there all at once.