There are no circumstances under which it is going to make sense to overturn the final result of a game based on one or more bad calls. No matter how much it hurts, or seems unfair, bad calls are simply part of the game. Replay is supposed to give us the opportunity to fix many of them during the game, but, once the game is over, it is over.
I remember the year in basketball when Wake got screwed by two last minute calls - one that awarded a field goal to the other team even though it was released just after the final buzzer and the other that awarded the other team a 3-pointer even though replay showed the shooter's toe to be on the line. This was before instant replay so they couldn't be fixed during the game. But, it was obvious after the fact that we got screwed and should have won the game. Did anyone start a movement to have the results of the games overturned? Hell no.
It is so perfect that it is only when it is Duke that has been wronged that now people are trying to argue that the game result should be reversed. Ridiculous concept.