Thief getting widely panned in reviews; 69 on Metacritic. That's disappointing.
I was bummed by that too. I went ahead and took the plunge. Played about 3 hours so far.
The gameplay is actually really great. I enjoyed the first 2 level designs, and the options available to you as you sneak around are pretty cool. There are lots of rich details scattered about the game, too--little documents, trinkets, etc. Best of all, imo, money actually
means something in this game. I actively explore around the map and seek out side quests because I badly need the cash.
BUT the story/voice acting is garbage, and all the audio in the game seems really buggy. I frequently hear people's conversations when I'm deep underground or in an unoccupied house, for some reason. The frame rate can get really choppy during cinematics, which sucks, and there are frequent load screens that take longer than I'd like.
And this can be good/bad depending on your view, but the game will absolutely punish you if you make a mistake. Guards almost always kick your ass, falling from a rooftop will kill you, and traps around the levels will kill you pretty much instantly. It's pretty old school.