What is the best sandwich?

[PaddyWF]

Chicken cutlet with lettuce, tomato, provolone, oil & vinegar was done by an Italian deli near me that was also excellent.

Good roast beef on rye toast is also worth a mention.

 

[BarcaDeac]

Reuben
Roast beef debris po boy
Banh mi
Lamb gyro
Muffuletta
Italian sub

 

[redwing42]

Muffaletta, Reuben, Cheesesteak, Cuban, BLT. No particular order.

 

[Wakeforest22890]

Go on....

(my guess - Cutty's, I don't read the chat thread so I wouldn't have seen your prior mentions of this shop.

Yeah it’s Cuttys. Honestly all their sandwiches are delicious - pimento grilled cheese also a go to

 

[1976Deac]

This is number one. It is difficult to get it all right. But when it is, incredible. And I don't think I've had one in 10 years.

Pizza Garden!

 

[TimmyClutch]

Reuben
Roast beef debris po boy
Banh mi
Lamb gyro
Muffuletta
Italian sub

Is this your top 6 in order?

 

[BarcaDeac]

Is this your top 6 in order?

It’s what came to mind. Reuben is probs #1

 

[TimmyClutch]

It’s what came to mind. Reuben is probs #1

You don’t seem very sure

 

[BarcaDeac]

You don’t seem very sure

I’m sure those are all good sandwiches

 

[mako1331]

Fresh garden tomato BLT is gonna be my pick, but it's tough.

 

[bym051d]

Fresh garden tomato BLT is gonna be my pick, but it's tough.

Heavily dependent on tomato quality.

 

[mako1331]

The best sandwich I've ever made was rye toast, egg straight from my chickens, fried prosciutto, avocado, and a Cherokee Purple right out of the garden with a little salt and pepper. I remember the day I made it four years on July 18th. It may have been the pinnacle of my existence.

 

[TownieDeac]

The best sandwich I've ever made was rye toast, egg straight from my chickens, fried prosciutto, avocado, and a Cherokee Purple right out of the garden with a little salt and pepper. I remember the day I made it four years on July 18th. It may have been the pinnacle of my existence.

No cheese or condiments? How was the egg prepared?

I’m worried this will be like the chat thread dip conversation, and I won’t be able to contain myself

 

[Deacsfan27]

Either a lobster roll or a French dip for me.

 

[mako1331]

No cheese or condiments? How was the egg prepared?

I’m worried this will be like the chat thread dip conversation, and I won’t be able to contain myself

The avocado was the condiment. I forgot the smoked Gouda. The egg was over medium.

 

[BarcaDeac]

Either a lobster roll or a French dip for me.

Connecticut or Maine?

 

[bmoneydeac]

Lobster rolls are certainly tasty but I feel like they are always smaller than I expect and a few dollars more expensive.

 

[deac03]

Fried oyster po boy, fully dressed on a French roll or leidenheimer bread

 

[WindyCityDeac]

The best sandwich I've ever made was rye toast, egg straight from my chickens, fried prosciutto, avocado, and a Cherokee Purple right out of the garden with a little salt and pepper. I remember the day I made it four years on July 18th. It may have been the pinnacle of my existence.

i need to be very honest with all of you right now. my nipples started tingling when i read this

 

[BarcaDeac]

Fried oyster po boy, fully dressed on a French roll or leidenheimer bread

Po boys rule.

What’s our best sandwich city?

New Orleans (muffuletta, po boy, banh mi)
Philly (cheesesteak, roast pork and rabe, hoagies)
NYC (pastrami/other deli, Italian sub, BEC, chopped cheese, HOT DOG)
LA (French dip, tortas, reubens/other deli)